Ron Resnick

I have loved music since almost as early as I can remember. My father worked in the record business all of his life (Columbia Records, then Arista then Atlantic and WEA Music Group). He took me to many, many concerts when I was growing up.

High-end audio became my primary hobby in 1988. I was working in Manhattan, and so I enjoyed establishing relationships with Michael Kay of Lyric Hi-Fi, Andy Singer and Elliot Fishkin. At Lyric Mike played for me the Infinity IRS V system driven by Jadis JA200s with the Goldmund Reference turntable. Listening to Reference Recordings’ Symphony Fantastique on that system was a religious experience of the audio variety! I was hooked!

I have never been an equipment swapper. I have tried to identify the pieces of equipment which I enjoy the most and purchase them, even if they are expensive, and then just take fanatically good care of them so they last a long time.

Starting initially with Magnepan MG-IIIAs I progressed through a series of Martin-Logan speakers. I had Martin-Logan Monoliths and then Monolith IIIs and then Prodigys for many years. I have always loved vocals on electrostatic panels and ribbon panels.

Effective February 18, 2016, I became a Senior Contributing Reviewer for Mono and Stereo.

To better understand my reviews and the context in which I make my comments I want to explain my high-end audio philosophy, my listening biases and my music preferences. By so doing I hope that my reviews and my descriptions of what I hear will be more valuable to you. By enabling you to understand my preferences, and by helping you to calibrate what I like versus what you like, I hope to enable you to triangulate meaningfully on, and better comprehend, what I describe in my reviews.

I believe there are four primary, but not mutually exclusive, alternative objectives of high-end audio:

1) recreate the sound of an original musical event,

2) reproduce exactly what is on the master tape,

3) create a sound subjectively pleasing to the audiophile, and

4) create a sound that seems live.

I subscribe to the first and fourth objectives. I want my audio system to recreate as realistically and as believably as possible the sound of an original musical event, and a sound that seems live. Several conclusions immediately follow from this particular philosophy.

1) I do not care how a piece of equipment measures.

2) I do not care about the theory behind the design of a component (Actually, I do care, but only because I find theory and component design very interesting. But, ultimately, I care only about the resulting sound. I avoid most theory and design threads because I am not dogmatic about particular theories or about particular designs, and because I believe that the implementation is far more important than the theory. This is why turntables of many different designs can all sound good.)

3) I am open-minded about tweaks.

My main musical interest is vocals with minimal acoustic instrument accompaniment. Examples include Sarah McLachlan singing while playing the piano on Fumbling Towards Ecstasy, Jennifer Warnes on Famous Blue Raincoat and Amanda McBroom on Growing Up in Hollywood Town. I also like male vocal recordings such as Bill Henderson’s rendition of “Send in the Clowns” and Jeff Buckley’s Grace.

I like a little bit of jazz such as Dave Brubeck’s Time Out, “For Duke” and Bill Evan’s “Waltz for Debby.” I like a little bit of classical including Mozart Jupiter Symphony 41 and Mussorgsky’s Night on Bald Mountain and Pictures at an Exhibition. I am a big fan of direct-to-disc recordings by Sheffield Lab and M&K RealTime.

I enjoy a lot of perfectly ordinary rock and pop songs (e.g., Bruce Springsteen, Fleetwood Mac, Whitney Houston, Michael Jackson, New Order, Phil Collins, Elton John, Jim Croce, Billy Joel, the Cranberries) and a lot of 1980s songs from “one-hit wonders.” I listen for the believability of a solo vocalist with acoustic instrument accompaniment being present in my listening room and singing to me. I value most highly transparency, no artificial brightness, true-to-life corporeal and instrumental "body," true-to-life dynamics and true-to-life harmonic richness.

I tend to be fascinated by the various non-traditional loudspeaker technologies: electrostatic, ribbon, magnetic planar, MBL, horn, etc. Planar speakers in general (my first speaker was the Magnepan MG-IIIA) and electrostatic speakers in particular (such as the MartinLogans) have always interested me because I like what I consider to be their see-through transparency which makes it sound as though a solo vocalist is singing to me in my living room. I also like the oomph and impact (i.e, cone excursion impact) of dynamic driver speakers and subwoofers.

To my ears, horns, at their best, can reproduce jazz and classical music with greater instrumental body and weight, greater “jump factor,” and greater overall realism than any other speaker technology I have heard. There seems to be something about the way horns move air which allows a greater suspension of disbelief on instruments like saxophone, tuba, trumpet, etc. Those instruments sound on horns more real and more “in-the-room being played by a live musician” than I have heard from any other type of speaker.

No loudspeaker is perfect. Different speakers excel at reproducing realistically different things. Some speaker designs excel at reproducing realistically certain instruments but not voices, and other speaker designs excel at reproducing voices and other instruments.

While my desire for electrostatic midrange transparency and the openness of dipoles has caused me not to be terribly interested in full-range dynamic driver loudspeakers, I nonetheless like the cone excursion impact of dynamic drivers for low frequencies. This is why I have been drawn for the last 28 years to MartinLogan hybrids.

I have some seemingly unusual sensitivity to brightness and edginess. Screeching brakes on buses and trucks give me literally an instant headache. I find unappealing any audio system, and any component thereof, which sounds edgy or artificially bright. I had a brief affair the weekend of T.H.E. Show 2015 with the amazingly realistic and dynamic MBL 101E Mk. II. But after listening to the MBL speaker for five hours that weekend, and for several hours at a friend’s house with tube electronics and vinyl, and after much research and discussion, I could not avoid the conclusion that the MBL sound is simply is too hot for me.

I have always preferred tube electronics because I find that there is a wonderful synergy with tubes on electrostatic panels. I have never heard solid-state amplifiers drive electrostatic panels and sound rich and natural and liquid the way tubes sound to me. I hear the greater dynamics and leading-edge transients and detail of solid-state amplification, but it always sounds a bit dry to me, especially on electrostatic panels. In addition I believe that MartinLogans like a lot of power (and I believe that Magnepans need a lot of power). So high power tube amplifiers have always been the correct answer for me.

I heard the Aesthetix Io all-tube, dedicated phono preamplifier at one of Jim White’s first dealers, and I was hooked immediately. I hear from the Io richness and bloom and detail and decay and liquidness that I appreciated from day one and from which I have never tired.

I resent expensive cables. I know that different cables sound different. But I think the whole expensive cable thing is a morass. I believe that a network which contains a resistor, an inductor and a capacitor (a basic R-L-C circuit, which is also known as a tuned circuit) is a simple tone control.

I believe that many debates and conflicting opinions about format preferences and equipment preferences and sound preferences arise from audiophiles holding different views on their objective of high-end audio, and from starting the debate with those different objectives not explicitly in mind.

I also believe that much other consternation arises simply from the well-known incomparability of interpersonal utility (e.g., there is no objective, principled way to prove that you like chocolate ice cream more than I like vanilla ice cream).

I think we all hear substantially the same thing in the concert hall. So why do we end up with audio systems which sound very different?

Audio components don’t reproduce sound perfectly — either the sound of a single acoustic instrument played live in front of us in a small room, or the overall sonic experience we enjoy in the concert hall. We don’t achieve 100% suspension of disbelief while listening to our stereo systems.

Since our audio components collectively cannot re-create the entire experience we feel in the concert hall each of us chooses components that re-create those particular attributes of sound we hear in the concert hall which subjectively maximize our personal suspension of disbelief. Which particular attributes of sound are most important to us as conduits to maximizing our personal suspension of disbelief is subjective. Different audio components will be used by different audiophiles to achieve certain particular attributes of sound. This is why our different stereo systems sound so different, even though we all are hearing substantially the same thing in the concert hall.

How each of us chooses to replicate at home with an audio system an experience similar to the experience in the concert hall is subjective. This is why there is no one, same “world’s best [component]” for all audiophiles.
Location
Beverly Hills, CA
The Place To List Your Gear
Vintage Audio Specialties American Sound AS-2000 and Nothing racks, Adona GXT1Ns
SME 3012R
Grado Epoch 3
ZXY UNIverse Premium X-SB2
Studer A820
Denon TU-900
Aesthetix Io Eclipse with 2 power supplies
Pioneer Elite DV-47Ai
Innuos PULSEmini
Lampizator Baltic 3
VTL TL-7.5 Series III
VTL Siegfried II
Gryphon Audio Designs Pendragon
Belden 1192A and Cardas Clear Beyond interconnects
Iconoclast BAV and Cardas Clear Beyond XL power cables
Absolute Fidelity speaker cable
Dalby Lignum Vitae V8 record weight
JPS in-wall wire, PS Audio outlets with two chemical grounds
Shakti Stones
self-propelled, sound-absorbing cocker-poo dog

My dedicated listening space is 19.75' wide X 24.5' long X 14.5' high. The space opens to a kitchen on the left side and opens to an equipment room on the right side. The turntable, tape machine, pre-amplifiers, record cleaner and LPs are located in an adjacent equipment room.
The Place To List Your Reference Tracks
"The Rose" by Amanda McBroom, Growing Up in Hollywood Town (Sheffield Lab 13)

"Send in the Clowns" by Bill Henderson, Live at the Times (Jazz Planet Records/Classic Records)

"Landslide" by Fleetwood Mac, Fleetwood Mac (MFSL)

"First We Take Manhattan" and "Bird on a Wire" by Jennifer Warnes, Famous Blue Raincoat (Rock the House Records/Classic Records)*

"I've Got the Music in Me" by Thelma Houston, I've Got the Music in Me (Sheffield Lab 2)

“Pictures at an Exhibition” on The Power of the Orchestra, Rene Leibowitz, RPO, Chesky RC30

*Yes, I know this is a digital recording.
Gender
Male
Occupation
High-End Audio Journalist

Contact

ICQ
1

Signature

Mono and Stereo - Senior Contributing Reviewer

Dealer for Clarisys Audio and Hegel Music Systems


TURNTABLE: Brinkmann Balance; RoNt III; Dalby Lignum Vitae V8; TONEARM: Graham Phantom Elite, Reed 5T; CARTRIDGE: Grado Epoch 3, ZYX UNIverse Premium X-SB2; TAPE: Studer A820; CD PLAYER: Pioneer Elite DV-47Ai; STREAMER: Innuos PULSEmini; Linear Tube Audio LPS+; DAC: Lampizator Baltic 4; TUNER: Denon TU-900; PHONO STAGE: Aesthetix Io Eclipse, Hegel V10; LINE STAGE: VTL TL-7.5 Series III, Hegel P30A; AMPLIFIER: Jadis JA100; LOUDSPEAKER: Gryphon Pendragon, Clarisys Studio Plus; INTERCONNECT CABLE: Cardas Clear Beyond, Cardas Clear Reflection; SPEAKER CABLE: Absolute Fidelity; POWER CABLE: Cardas Clear Beyond XL, Iconoclast BAV; POWER: dedicated sub-panel, JPS in-wall, chemical grounds; STANDS: HRS M3X2, PBN Audio turntable stand, Adona Zero GXT1N; ROOM: 20' wide X 24' long X 14' tall; ACOUSTIC TREATMENT: PSI AVAAs, ASC TubeTraps, absorption panels; WOO-WOO: Shakti Stones, Saraswati

Trophies

  1. 200

    2000 Trophy Points

    you have reached 2000 trophy points
  2. 200

    Trophy Achiever

    You have 2000 trophy points
  3. 50

    Trophy Master

    you have 2000 trophy points
  4. 500

    10000 Likes

    you have received 10000 likes
  5. 100

    Always Liked

    you have 9000 likes
  6. 100

    white beard

    you have been registered for 3000 days
  7. 100

    Always Liked

    you have 8000 likes
  8. 100

    Forever Liked

    you have 7000 likes
  9. 100

    Still Liked

    You have at least 6000 likes
  10. 100

    Forever Liked

    You have received 5000 likes
  11. 100

    Trophy Zen

    You have 1000 trophy points
  12. 50

    Trophy Tops

    You have at least 1000 trophy points
  13. 50

    Keep Posting

    You have added 10000 posts
  14. 100

    Likeable You

    you have 4500 likes
  15. 25

    Day Dream

    You have been registered for 2500 days
  16. 100

    Seriously liked

    You have 4000 likes
  17. 60

    Loving You

    Content you have posted has been liked 3500 times
  18. 50

    Crazy Love

    Content you have posted has been liked 3000 times
  19. 50

    We Really Love you

    Content you have posted has been liked 2500 times
  20. 20

    Day Delight

    you have been registered for 2000 days
  21. 20

    Trophy Zen

    You have at least 500 Trophy Points
  22. 50

    Long time user

    You have been registered for 1000 days
  23. 50

    Can you feel The Love

    Content you have posted has been liked 2000 times
  24. 30

    Love Is In The Air

    Content you have posted has been liked 1500 times
  25. 10

    Trophy Master

    you have at least 300 trophy points
  26. 50

    Super Moderator

    Your user group is Super Moderator
  27. 100

    Administrator

    Your user group is administrator
  28. 2

    Avatar Achievement

    Your username has an avatar
  29. 15

    Day After Day

    You have been registered for 1500 days
  30. 10

    Day Zen

    You have been registered for 1000 days
  31. 5

    Day Master

    You have been registered for 500 days
  32. 5

    Trophy Delight

    You have at least 100 trophy points
  33. 40

    We Love Your Posts

    You have added at least 5000 posts
  34. 15

    Positive Poster

    You have added at least 2000 posts
  35. 10

    Poster Master

    You have added at least 1000 posts
  36. 5

    Mad Poster

    You have added 500 messages
  37. 30

    More Love

    Content you have posted has been liked 1000 times
  38. 30

    I LOVE IT!

    Content you have posted has attracted 500 positive reactions.
  39. 20

    Can't Get Enough of Your Stuff

    Your content has been positively reacted to 250 times.
  40. 15

    Seriously Likeable!

    Content you have posted has attracted a positive reaction score of 100.
  41. 10

    I Like It a Lot

    Your messages have been positively reacted to 25 times.
  42. 2

    Somebody Likes You

    Somebody out there reacted positively to one of your messages. Keep posting like that for more!
  43. 20

    Addicted

    1,000 messages? Impressive!
  44. 10

    Can't Stop!

    You've posted 100 messages. I hope this took you more than a day!
  45. 5

    Keeps Coming Back

    30 messages posted. You must like it here!
  46. 1

    First Message

    Post a message somewhere on the site to receive this.

About us

  • What’s Best Forum is THE forum for high end audio, product reviews, advice and sharing experiences on the best of everything else. This is THE place where audiophiles and audio companies discuss vintage, contemporary and new audio products, music servers, music streamers, computer audio, digital-to-analog converters, turntables, phono stages, cartridges, reel-to-reel tape machines, speakers, headphones and tube and solid-state amplification. Founded in 2010 What’s Best Forum invites intelligent and courteous people of all interests and backgrounds to describe and discuss the best of everything. From beginners to life-long hobbyists to industry professionals, we enjoy learning about new things and meeting new people, and participating in spirited debates.

Quick Navigation

User Menu

Steve Williams
Site Founder | Site Owner | Administrator
Ron Resnick
Site Co-Owner | Administrator
Julian (The Fixer)
Website Build | Marketing Managersing