Let's pretend, if you may, that I've been around long enough to know what "soul" is in relation to the emotional context of music for any playback device, or Live for that matter ... but ... if you prefer certain colorations brought on by certain resonances, then who am I to argue. I prefer my...
The SAT arm is all about controlling resonance ... so after hearing Fremer's rips with the SAT arm, I did some digging (as I've done so many times before) ...
below (not scaled) ... is the right channel freq.resp from a recent Fremer rip using a $10K cart and the SAT arm. The red trace is...
Perhaps the many MANY issues in regard to maintaining correct groove/stylus interface, plus the myriad of other resonance issues related to colorations within the analog chain ... are far more negative in nature when compared to tracking distortion.
big sigh, as stated, I think most analog reviews without proof (rips) are useless ... when it comes to resonance control ... I came to the above conclusion based on actual hands on experience working with, and modifying MANY turntables.
a blanket statement, it really depends on the eq at hand ... since it is impossible to kill "all" resonance within the analog chain ... I prefer the word control.
When it comes to analog, resonance gets generated, then travels from TT to Arm, to Cart, and then, unfortunately ... back again...
Yet, you also posted this nonsense ... "I claim and continue to claim that his preoccupation with avoiding resonances at every level of playback is overblown and misguided."
If you can't understand the massive negative influence of resonances ... well ...
Well, not only does he compare, but he also provides rips which allow the reader to hear the product in question. To my knowledge, he is the one doing that ...
Thankfully Fremer has gotten over his silly "hate" for all things digital and in turn has used it as a viable tool for comparison...
... tilted scales ... dynamic range measurements have since confirmed that many so called "superior" SACDs inc. a compressed CD layer.
No wonder many think SACD sounds better.
http://qz.com/778011/sully-ntsb-investigators-are-not-happy-about-being-made-the-villains-in-clint-eastwoods-film-starring-tom-hanks-as-chesley-sully-sullenberger/
http://www.cbsnews.com/news/former-ntsb-investigators-have-beef-with-movie-sully/
It's NOT their job to be antagonistic...
Clint / Hollywood often mixes fact with entertainment value and creative license.
NTSB report ...
http://www.ntsb.gov/investigations/AccidentReports/Reports/AAR1003.pdf
"Simulation flights were run to determine whether the accident flight could have landed successfully at LGA or TEB...
CD has fine DR values ...
foobar2000 1.3.9 / Dynamic Range Meter 1.1.1
log date: 2016-09-06 18:48:09
DR Peak RMS Duration Track
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
DR13 0.00 dB -15.52 dB 4:20 ?-01 Track01...