Scientists overhear two atoms "chatting"


VIP/Donor & WBF Founding Member
May 6, 2010
Boston, MA

Atoms, of course, don't really talk. But they can react to each other. This is particularly the case for magnetic atoms. "Each atom carries a small magnetic moment called spin. These spins influence each other, like compass needles do when you bring them close together. If you give one of them a push, they will start moving together in a very specific way," explains Sander Otte, leader of the team that performed the research. "But according to the laws of quantum mechanics, each spin can be simultaneously point in various directions, forming a superposition. This means that actual transfer of quantum information takes place between the atoms, like some sort of conversation."

Sharp needle

On a large scale, this kind of exchange of information between atoms can lead to fascinating phenomena. A classic example is superconductivity: the effect where some materials lose all electrical resistivity below a critical temperature. While well understood for the simplest cases, nobody knows exactly how this effect comes about in many complex materials. But it's certain that magnetic quantum interactions play a key role. For the purpose of trying to explaining phenomena like this, scientists are very interested in being able to intercept these exchanges; to overhear the conversations between atoms.

In Otte's team they go about this rather directly: they literally put two atoms next to each other to see what happens. This is possible by virtue of a scanning tunneling microscope: a device in which a sharp needle can probe atoms one-by-one and can even rearrange them. The researchers used this device to place two titanium atoms at a distance of just over one nanometer—one millionth of a millimeter—apart. At that distance, the atoms are just able to detect each other's spin. If you would now twist one of the two spins, the conversation would start by itself.

Usually, this twist is performed by sending very precise radio signals to the atoms. This so-called spin resonance technique—which is quite reminiscent of the working principle of an MRI scanner found in hospitals—is used successfully in research on quantum bits. This tool is also available to the Delft team, but it has a disadvantage. "It is simply too slow," says Ph.D. student Lukas Veldman, lead author on the Science publication. "You have barely started twisting the one spin before the other starts to rotate along. This way you can never investigate what happens upon placing the two spins in opposite directions."

Unorthodox approach

So the researchers tried something unorthodox: they rapidly inverted the spin of one of the two atoms with a sudden burst of electric current. To their surprise, this drastic approach resulted in a beautiful quantum interaction, exactly by the book. During the pulse, electrons collide with the atom, causing its spin to rotate. Otte: "But we always assumed that during this process, the delicate quantum information—the so-called coherence—was lost. After all, the electrons are incoherent: the history of each electron prior to the collision is slightly different and this chaos is transferred to the atom's spin, destroying any coherence."

The fact that this now seems not to be true was cause for some debate. Apparently, each random electron, regardless of its past, can initiate a coherent superposition: a specific combination of elementary quantum states which is fully known and which forms the basis for almost any form of quantum technology.

Perfect superposition

"The crux is that it depends on the question you ask," argues Markus Ternes, co-author from the RWTH Aachen University and the Research Center Jülich. "The electron inverts the spin of one atom causing it to point, say, to the left. You could view this as a measurement, erasing all quantum memory. But from the point of view of the combined system comprising both atoms, the resulting situation is not so mundane at all. For the two atoms together, the new state constitutes a perfect superposition, enabling the exchange of information between them. Crucially for this to happen is that both spins become entangled: a peculiar quantum state in which they share more information about each other than classically possible."

The discovery can be of importance to research on quantum bits. Perhaps also in that research you could get away with being slightly less careful when initializing quantum states. But for Otte and his team it is mostly the starting point of even more beautiful experiments. Veldman: "here we used two atoms, but what happens when you use three? Or ten, or a thousand? Nobody can predict that, as computing power falls short for such numbers. Perhaps one day we will be able to listen to quantum conversations that nobody could ever hear before."


Well-Known Member
Jul 23, 2018
This will be something that impacts on the Hifi of the future!
Aug 23, 2021
Yes,this is getting interesting and much more up my sleeve.The world of quantum mechanics are really a mysterious world.We learn every day but it is so enormously big and the more we learn ,the more it baffles our brains.

I been lecturing these subjects for many years to young students and after 35 years are daily baffled again.Just if you think you understand it,somebody comes out with a new theory and you start all over again.

Will we benefit from all these new achievements,yes for sure,we are already doing it.Without quantum mechanics,nothing can work.Do we understand everything,No we will never,but we learning daily and hopefully one day we can bring the small puzzles together and it will make more sense.

The only theory I understand fully is the chaos Theory,my desk is getting daily more of a mess,just a joke.

Atoms or sub atomic substances can all influence each other and over a very big distance,sometimes,but like these clever people were writing in the paper, how they will react on big scale ,we can only predict.Sometimes our imagination is far too small and the outcome is very different.It is sometimes very disturbing,you work on a theory for years and you got the Mathematics to support it and one morning you wake up and someone you never heard about,on the otherside of the world,found out something completely different.It has happened to me many many times and years later you find out that you were actually on the right track,but now 15 years later you lost the insight completely and to work you way into the subject again takes many years .
Somebody should design a quantum Amplifier,if someone got the knowledge,please do it and if he or she will get it right ,this should sound great,or maybe not.This is the quantum world,nobody can predict anything.

Cheers and let your imagination take you on a wild trip and believe me,all our imagination put together is still far too small,this is a weird world.

Great thread
  • Like
Reactions: iain

About us

  • What’s Best Forum is THE forum for high end audio, product reviews, advice and sharing experiences on the best of everything else. This is THE place where audiophiles and audio companies discuss vintage, contemporary and new audio products, music servers, music streamers, computer audio, digital-to-analog converters, turntables, phono stages, cartridges, reel-to-reel tape machines, speakers, headphones and tube and solid-state amplification. Founded in 2010 What’s Best Forum invites intelligent and courteous people of all interests and backgrounds to describe and discuss the best of everything. From beginners to life-long hobbyists to industry professionals, we enjoy learning about new things and meeting new people, and participating in spirited debates.

Quick Navigation

User Menu

Steve Williams
Site Founder | Site Owner | Administrator
Ron Resnick
Site Co-Owner | Administrator
Julian (The Fixer)
Website Build | Marketing Managersing