St John's or St Matthew? The best concert I ever saw was St Matthews passion. I also saw a boring version of it. It is three hours long so all performers need magic. And gets performed only during Easter.
Another list of the top ten classical composers
- Thread starter Don C
- Start date
St John's or St Matthew? The best concert I ever saw was St Matthews passion. I also saw a boring version of it. It is three hours long so all performers need magic. And gets performed only during Easter.
You bet. Each one of Mahler's symphony is a story or vision. I could no more listen to it in parts then watch just one part of a feature film and call it a day. When I listen to Mahler, it's a serious listening commitment. At least for me.
Looking forward to M6 in Chicago in 3 days right before heading to AXPONA.
I would refute Mahler in my personal list in favor of the closely associated Krenek. An intellectual decision with basis in among other acts, refusing to finish the mad final symphony for sale under immediate pressure by the family he had by this point joined. It is this very refusal at deep personal cost which allows deeper examination of greatness. I look not at the incessant flattery of music for kings nor ploys towards mortal sensationalism in depicting what formative basis a composer is valued above others at the moment a decision is being rendered. Nor do I find my own personal critiques anything but silliness if impacting the listening enjoyment of others.
Math and science could lose importance in the next grain of sand to fall. Shoving humane elements to the fore. Social examination among social beings is a very powerful force. Where it grows increasingly hard to recognize the world as it was in 1600. Retaking the ground laid more recently makes the work no less impactful. It has never been about surpassing the height of previous generations shoulders. In reality standing tall enough to draw level remains the challenge.
Math and science could lose importance in the next grain of sand to fall. Shoving humane elements to the fore. Social examination among social beings is a very powerful force. Where it grows increasingly hard to recognize the world as it was in 1600. Retaking the ground laid more recently makes the work no less impactful. It has never been about surpassing the height of previous generations shoulders. In reality standing tall enough to draw level remains the challenge.
The question I put myself was if I was going to that desert island what could I survive on so all these are just those I see greatness in, composers whose work I find the most compelling and captivating. More than anything I suppose it’s about resonating with their works and their spirit. Ravel was in my early list but didn’t survive the final pare back. I admire his work but considered that I don’t play much of it. So it was more about natural attrition. Barber is there for much of his work though for his concertos especially. Brahms and Schubert would be among the last to be cut if I had to reduce even more.
Last edited:
Overture to "The School for Scandal" !
Have you heard Schubert's Great (9th symphony) and his leider like winterreise? And you don't like them?
Peter Schreier and Winterreise, a sure classic.
Schubert's Great and the 8th symphony (The Unfinished) really have that divine spark that Beethoven is reported to have spoken of when he looked at some of Schubert's works.
I totally love Schubert's music.
+1 on that. My favourite Samuel Barber works are the piano concerto and violin concerto and very closely followed by the cello concerto, but for me all of these are great but I’d also add Knoxville Summer of 1915.
Liszt said of
Liszt said Schubert was the most poetic of composers, for me Chopin also shares that extraordinary musical poetry.
Did someone say Schubert? How about a quintet.
Lots of these on the tube, the storied one is Du Pre, Perlman, Mehta, Barenboim, Zuckerman when they were young - a realistic Schubertium - though more about them than the music. This one has music and Mutter - so so, but I stopped looking.
Chopin? a seducer...
Schubert - "Trout" Quintet - The Audio Beat - www.TheAudioBeat.com
read audio reviews, ratings, and user opinions on audio equipment before you buy an audio system
www.theaudiobeat.com
Lots of these on the tube, the storied one is Du Pre, Perlman, Mehta, Barenboim, Zuckerman when they were young - a realistic Schubertium - though more about them than the music. This one has music and Mutter - so so, but I stopped looking.
Chopin? a seducer...
This is an audiophile forum, people are unfamiliar with both
Talking seduction… or was it abduction… Schubert’s Death and the Maiden. Schubert’s abduction and seduction were fairly much one and the same. Such extraordinarily poignant music making composing while facing death. His song like lyricism and meaningful and soulful context was for me at the very core of his greatness.
Love Winterreise. The great just bores the hell out of me. I keep revisiting every so often hoping something will spark. Maybe one day. I also appreciate his piano sonatas. I just don't see him as one of the greats.
Similar threads
