I've done the Telegraph test too and IMO it has nothing to do with the original test.
First of all they should have used a competent violinist. Even an average music student would do better.
Then the recording is technically mediocre at best. Stereo image isn't stable and the three versions...
Hej Erik, nice to see you here.
Erik and I were classmates (rec.eng.) in the early 80's when splicing analog tape was the only way to edit. I still have my BASF antimagnetic scissors, but hope to never use them again. Digital editing is incomparably more sophisticated (and non destructive)...
Attempts to improve ADC filters was already done in 1986 by Apogee.
These could be installed in several multitrack recorder brands. To me it makes sense to apply the correction as early as possible in the chain. Especially in modern music production where many (different) ADC signals (and even...
There's a refreshing version for string orchestra by Sitkovetsky, an adaptation of his own trio version. (amazon).
A version with video by Barenboim, here on youtube or amazon.
The interesting thing is that iZotope SRC artifacts are below -150dBFS in the (<21kHz) passband. This should not be audible, unless the monitoring adds audible distortion, or unless you can hear above 21 kHz.
Have you tried the iZotope SRC only, without reducing the wordlength to 16 bit ? I've found iZotope SRC to be transparent below 21kHz. Dither is another story.
The new audio tool RX4 from iZotope just came out. One of its new features is that its SRC no longer produces subsample delay in the output. This has no sonic advantages but it allows to use a null test to demonstrate the accuracy of the process. Default settings result in a difference signal...
Amir, I'm downloading the files right now and will give it a try. Do you have any idea about the spl you were monitoring at ? IME this is crucial for audibility of low level noise. Everyone has a hearing threshold :)
I'm not aware of any "formal" definition of fast bass.
The fastest (double) bass I've ever heard (attack/decay) was during open air concerts. Absence of reverberation helps.
A slow bass could be something like this:
(is there a way to resize images?)
Are you referring to Convention Paper 9174 by Meridian? Luckily they tested filter and wordlength/dither aspects separately. I hope they found a few well trained listeners. Looks interesting.
IMO you're a bit hard on Sonic. AFAIK the gain reduction is a leftover from the days that Sonic used fixed point processing. Any clipping in the process would be permanent, unlike floating point. I don't know if Sonic is still using fixed point though. Even the highly respected Weiss Saracon SRC...
Like you I always believed that higher fidelity systems allow better discrimination of artifacts, until I learned from lossy audio experts that unmasking is an important aspect of revealing artifacts. Some not so good or even broken systems might do a better job at unmasking than high fidelity...
There are several level differences, so I'm not quite sure which ones you mean and I have trouble finding anything in the huge AVS thread :)
AFAIK the 0.2 dB level difference was between the original 3 AVS music samples, caused by the specific (Sonic Studio) SRC. This only concerns level...
Amir, afaik the 4kHz tone is at -30dBFS peak and -33dB RMS level. If you go nearly deaf, doesn't that indicate that your monitoring level is rather high? Have you verified that your chain is not adding audible distortion at that level? When I did an ABX on my MacBook with cheap headphones I...