Yeah, I'm not crazy about ASR's assumptions and confirmational biases either. There are plenty of electromagnetic and psychoacoustical parameters which can't be quantified through mere "measurements". For example, in my Feb 2021 shoot-out between the "measures perfectly" Topping D90 DAC + A90 preamplifier combo (which at the time was the top components measured by ASR), and the MSB Technologies Select II DAC (with dual powerBases), which do you think won? Did they even sound remotely alike? Nope, not even close!
judging cause and effect, and understanding the why is important......even though you can't always understand the real reasons for things. the idea of getting beyond that 'tipping point' is a concept that has been my experience. which is why to judge most tweaks you need to reach a level of...
www.whatsbestforum.com
Regarding auditions of the speakers mentioned above, I've heard them all - in very diverse setups, mostly sub-optimally, at dealers' showrooms, and Hi-End shows (see below):
2019: Hong Kong and Taipei
2022: AXPONA, Hong Kong, Singapore, Taipei, and Vietnam.
2023: AXPONA, Hong Kong, and Singapore
2024: Munich, Taipei, and Kuala Lumpur (soon)
My comments in the four (4) postings above are merely on the objective measurements published on HiFi News, so of course they are not final verdicts. However please do recognize that under standardized and uniform test conditions, side-by-side comparisons are actually very useful and valid. Take them for what they are.
Not surprisingly, however, there's actually a high correlation between these measurements and what I've heard in real-life situations. My loudspeaker preferences are those designs with minimal baffle diffraction, and maximally broad/uniform dispersion (both on-axis and off-axis, horizontally, and ideally, vertically too). Performance is not necessarily correlated linearly with MSRP, although the phenomena of ever-rising prices in goods/services which purport to deliver experiential pleasure whether imaginary or real, is very prominent nowadays, supported by strong consumption power among the well-resourced Baby Boomer demographic.
Indeed, it's tricky to navigate among the over-priced noise to find the sweet spot which delivers exceptional price/performance.
Those interested in my speaker-selection journey for my dedicated listening room, here are some of my postings to peruse:
UPDATED (2024-Sep): https://www.whatsbestforum.com/thre...uaddiffusors-big-dig.36359/page-7#post-993245
OLD (2024-Jun): https://www.whatsbestforum.com/thre...uaddiffusors-big-dig.36359/page-6#post-976565
OLD (2024-Apr): https://www.whatsbestforum.com/thre...uaddiffusors-big-dig.36359/page-6#post-962391
OLD (2023-May): https://www.whatsbestforum.com/thre...uaddiffusors-big-dig.36359/page-2#post-879524