Tom vs. JA on the Harbeth P3ESR

[kana813]

http://forum.stereophile.com/forum/s...ge=0#Post92693

Tom hasn't listen to or measured the Harbeth P3ESR, but felt the need to criticize JA's review of the Harbeth P3ES on REG's forum.

Guess he's just following REG's lead.

REG likes to use his forum to criticize JA's speaker reviews/measurements, but doesn't provide any measurements in his TAS speakers reviews.

 

[MylesBAstor]

See:

http://forum.stereophile.com/forum/showflat.php?Cat=0&Number=92693&an=0&page=0#Post92693

Tom hasn't listen to or measured the Harbeth P3ESR, but felt the need to criticize JA's review of the Harbeth P3ES on REG's forum.

Guess he's just following REG's lead.

REG likes to use his forum to criticize JA's speaker reviews/measurements, but doesn't provide any measurements in his TAS speakers reviews.

So correct me if I'm wrong but the conclusion is that one has to put their head in vise grip to appreciate the Harbeths?

 

[Gregadd]

http://forum.stereophile.com/forum/s...ge=0#Post92693

Tom hasn't listen to or measured the Harbeth P3ESR, but felt the need to criticize JA's review of the Harbeth P3ES on REG's forum.

Guess he's just following REG's lead.

REG likes to use his forum to criticize JA's speaker reviews/measurements, but doesn't provide any measurements in his TAS speakers reviews.

I am currently reading the review. I hope you would stay and provide a more detailed discussion of your dissatisfation. Perhaps you could send me a PM? If you are compeltely annoyed you can akways use the ignore button and find something here you like.