I prefer the first video (1:20)Here are the results of our two different approaches:
Enough said!
I prefer the first video (1:20)Here are the results of our two different approaches:
Enough said!
I prefer the first video (1:20)
All originals and remastered should be made from master tapes. Many remastered are made from pirate or unlawful copies. Remastered are not always better sound quality. I more like many older original recordings. Your works are from a copies (or copies of copies).Alex, answer this, if the original recording is the best possible, why do record companies issue remastered editions and claim better sound?
These type of exchanges do not reflect well on your understanding of the music mastering process.
All originals and remastered should be made from master tapes. Many remastered are made from pirate or unlawful copies. Remastered are not always better sound quality. I more like many older original recordings. Your works are from a copies (or copies of copies).
That confirms your source is not a master tape.For the record, my source files are from Tidal. The videos that I have recorded and submitted on this thread were streamed from Tidal. What do you have to say to that?
That confirms your source is not a master tape.
Al, the argument that some make is that it is possible under the right circumstances to get a good original LP on a superior vinyl front end to present more resolution/information (and sound more natural) than a digital version of that original analog recording through the system. It then follows that the resulting iPhone recording replayed over YouTube sounds better. If starting from a better sounding original presentation, the result in the end should also be better.
I understand that both are now digital recordings over YouTube, but one started out at a higher level, and some of that superiority is retained and heard through subsequent comparisons. That is the argument.
Yes indeed. Here's a Hilary Hahn video on YouTube. It sounds like a real violin on my modest speakers.Great, good for you. You are the one with the $25 Radio Shack desktop speakers correct?
Yes indeed. Here's a Hilary Hahn video on YouTube. It sounds like a real violin on my modest speakers.
Hilary Hahn - J.S. Bach: Partita for Violin Solo No. 1 in B Minor, BWV 1002 ----
I want you to succeed in audio field. Make $Billions. I want you to make an audio products which every one (includes women) enjoy. I really do.Carlos269
I will tell you this, the sound on my videos sound great and every time you post one of your videos with mine, they make mine sound even better. You are in business you should consider stopping the damage of the self inflicted wounds.
Peter, more resolution/information and more natural sound preserved through a cheap iPhone mic and a $1 ADC, presented through the digitally compressed AAC format as used by YouTube?
Sorry, this does not make any logical sense.
It is obvious that none of the videos posted comes close to the resolution/information and level of natural timbre heard from a good high end system in person, be it based on analog or digital source.
You are not listening closely Carlos...there is plenty of wood on this video.I don’t hear much wood on the Hilary Hahn video. Thanks for posting it. Very nice skill and flow. Will let others more akin to Classical music comment on the violin’s sound qualities on the video.
You are not listening closely Carlos...there is plenty of wood on this video.
You are not listening closely Carlos...there is plenty of wood on this video.
Oh yeah. Plenty.
Al you do not seem to understand.
No one is claiming that an iPhone recording sounds better than the original on the main system, but if what is being recorded is a good original LP and it starts out sounding better than the same music on an official YT video, then the resulting iPhone recording will sound better. Simple as that. Otherwise is faulty logic. The better sounding source will sound better over YouTube, all else being equal.
I am still trying to wrap my head around how it is you don't hear what is in the video. I don't have a way to play YouTube videos through my system...I will see what I can find in Qobuz.This is awesome. Since there is “plenty” of wood sound in this recording, let’s post some videos of our systems playing this track so we can evaluate how they compare to each other and to this video, of the Hilary Hahn recording. Al you go first, let get a video of your system playing this track. I will get a video during my next listening session.
A great example of what a solo violin sounds likeThis is awesome. Since there is “plenty” of wood sound in this recording, let’s post some videos of our systems playing this track so we can evaluate how they compare to each other and to this video, of the Hilary Hahn recording. Al you go first, let get a video of your system playing this track. I will get a video during my next listening session.
I am still trying to wrap my head around how it is you don't hear what is in the video. I don't have a way to play YouTube videos through my system...I will see what I can find in Qobuz.
A great example of what a solo violin sounds like
in the way a system presents the recording, possibly modulated through the iPhone recording process (which, for example, often adds a sense of reverb that by some is perceived as pleasant and can be mistaken for “hall information” or “liveliness”).
Steve Williams Site Founder | Site Owner | Administrator | Ron Resnick Site Co-Owner | Administrator | Julian (The Fixer) Website Build | Marketing Managersing |