HQPLAYER and High-Rate DSD Playback

Carlos269 said:
This is the endless component churn mentality that fuels the industry and empties the pockets of those less knowledgeable. Not for me any more, I know how to make my own wine to my liking and with HQPLAYER others can too.
Click to expand...
I appreciate and admire it. My work with Cinnamon stems from that, so I couldn't have it any other way.

But you believe you've cracked some code or achieved escape velocity from something? From my POV you appear to have simply traded convenience by time and effort, but are otherwise still orbiting the same sun as everybody else, at exactly the same orbit I'm afraid. Other people have other goals and stories in life. Why characterize people with different opinions in a dimmer light than yourself?
 
RCanelas said:
I appreciate and admire it. My work with Cinnamon stems from that, so I couldn't have it any other way.

But you believe you've cracked some code or achieved escape velocity from something? From my POV you appear to have simply traded convenience by time and effort, but are otherwise still orbiting the same sun as everybody else, at exactly the same orbit I'm afraid. Other people have other goals and stories in life. Why characterize people with different opinions in a dimmer light than yourself?
Click to expand...

I think that you are mischaracterizing my assertions. I’m like no other and no others are like me, let’s just leave it at that.
 
Alrainbow said:
Carlos do you use roon ?
Click to expand...
Yes I do. I use ROON for my music management.
Alrainbow said:
Do you use two pc Boards ?
Click to expand...
I use two separate custom built PC’s plus an NAA. One PC host ROON Core and the other PC host HQPLAYER and does the processing.
Alrainbow said:
I’ve had two pc main board systems for many years
your comment of pcm and dsd is I think spot on
and do prefer pcm for this reason
Click to expand...
Many will prefer the extra crisp presentation offered by PCM. With my Berkeley Audio Design Alpha Dac, PCM from HQPLAYER sounds fantastic and I greatly enjoy it.
Alrainbow said:
roon kills music in many ways but has gotten better
what is your pc server setup ?
Click to expand...
They are custom built based on the Intel 14900KS CPU and NVIDIA 4090 GPU.
Alrainbow said:
what kind of PSU used ?
Click to expand...
Platinum series Seasonic.
 
Could it be that only StreamFidelity and I are the only ones on this forum who have heard digital playback at its finest, HQPLAYER outputting DSD512x48 or DSD1024x48 to a chipless DSD digital to analog converter? There must be others who have experienced an optimized, per Jussi Laako’s guidance, HQPLAYER set up.
 
Last edited:
Carlos269 said:
Could it be that only StreamFidelity and I are the only ones on this forum who have heard digital playback at its finest, HQPLAYER outputting DSD512x48 or DSD1024x48 to a chipless DSD digital to analog converter? There must be others who have experienced an optimized, per Jussi Laako’s guidance, HQPLAYER set up.
Click to expand...
You might want to head over to Computeraudiophile and take a look at the DAC's which bypass processing for PCM or DSD. The assumption that you are the leader of the pack seems silly.
audiophilestyle.com

Which DACs bypass digital filtering?

I have been unsuccessfully searching for a list of high-performance* commercial DACs that allow user to bypass digital filtering (NOS), leaving that task to a software music player such as HQ Player. It would be interesting if we could compile such a list in this thread. * - no TDA1543-based DACs...
audiophilestyle.com audiophilestyle.com

MAK
 
  • Like
Reactions: Alrainbow and Carlos269
racerxnet said:
You might want to head over to Computeraudiophile and take a look at the DAC's which bypass processing for PCM or DSD. The assumption that you are the leader of the pack seems silly.
audiophilestyle.com

Which DACs bypass digital filtering?

I have been unsuccessfully searching for a list of high-performance* commercial DACs that allow user to bypass digital filtering (NOS), leaving that task to a software music player such as HQ Player. It would be interesting if we could compile such a list in this thread. * - no TDA1543-based DACs...
audiophilestyle.com audiophilestyle.com

MAK
Click to expand...

I’m familiar and have used discrete DSD chipless dacs for many years. As I mentioned before I currently own four different DSD512+ dacs that I use with HQPLAYER. Never mentioned being the leader of the pack in this regard. There are many users of similar equipment over at AudiophileStyle and DIYAudio who are at the same or similar level to what I am implementing.
 
Last edited:
I don’t post here very often but have spent quite a bit of time with HQPlayer so I thought I’d stick my 2 cents into this thread. I use Roon/HQPlayer in my headphone setup. That feeds a Sonore opticalRendu into a Holo Audio May KTE DAC. Because I had so much trouble getting HQP to play without dropouts I actually spent quite a bit of time listening to the May without it, both in NOS and with it’s built in upsampling. The sound with HQP was such a step up over the DAC without it that I kept after getting it to work properly and I’m really glad I did. I’ve experimented with DSD 512 but have settled on DSD 256 as my preference. Jussi considers DSD 256 to generally be the sweet spot and is what he uses in his own system.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jasond and Carlos269
Daverich4 said:
I don’t post here very often but have spent quite a bit of time with HQPlayer so I thought I’d stick my 2 cents into this thread. I use Roon/HQPlayer in my headphone setup. That feeds a Sonore opticalRendu into a Holo Audio May KTE DAC. Because I had so much trouble getting HQP to play without dropouts I actually spent quite a bit of time listening to the May without it, both in NOS and with it’s built in upsampling. The sound with HQP was such a step up over the DAC without it that I kept after getting it to work properly and I’m really glad I did. I’ve experimented with DSD 512 but have settled on DSD 256 as my preference. Jussi considers DSD 256 to generally be the sweet spot and is what he uses in his own system.
Click to expand...

Yes, the optimal rate is dac dependent. On my T+A DAC200 I’m currently using DSD512x48 instead of DSD1024. HQPLAYER is a game changer and as good as digital playback gets. Jussi has a lot of experience with both the Holo Audio May KTE DAC and the T+A DAC200. I’m aligned with Jussi’s settings with my DAC200 as well. Thank you for sharing your experience on here with your use of HQPLAYER outputting high-rate DSD to a chipless DSD digital to analog converter.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: jasond, Daverich4 and dan31
here is my two cents and I’ve also used roon hq two pc setups
yes HQ player can be an important change
compared to jriver where they are more centered
roon has had its ups and downs as its design is heavy cpu usage. Where j river is light
Im not a fan of up sample if on the fly
And built some very powerful main boards to play it on the fly
I have a few questions for anyone up sampling on the fly
what PSU are you using ?
a switching or Linear ?
answer this question please
 
Silence is deafening lol.
someone answer please.
If not I’ll give an answer later not to be rude but a possible reality check of audio sound
 
Carlos269 said:
In case anyone is wondering why the “chipless dac” requirement is crucial, it is because it avoids or eliminates any further digital processing of the data stream after HQPLAYER has processed and optimized it. Any digital processing of the data stream following HQPLAYER is detrimental to the resulting sound quality.

I know that @StreamFidelity on this forum listens to this HQPLAYER setup and it would be interesting to read his commentary and to see if he has done any direct or indirect comparisons with the Taiko sever & some of the favorite dacs on this forum to see how they compare sound wise to an optimal HQPLAYER digital playback system.

@StreamFidelity also lives in Germany and it would be interesting to hear if he heard any digital or analog systems at the Munich show that approach the level of resolution and detail that an optimized HQPLAYER based digital playback system can offer.
Click to expand...
I posted on another forum what I saw on some japanese sites reporting about the Digital Director being able to disable filters entirely, essentially making the MSB a NOS DAC.

Hope @Daniel Gullman or someone from MSB can verify this? If true, would be interesting for HQplayer users.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Carlos269
Alrainbow said:
Silence is deafening lol.
someone answer please.
If not I’ll give an answer later not to be rude but a possible reality check of audio sound
Click to expand...

Seasonic Prime Ultra Platinum switching power supply.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Alrainbow
shawnf said:
I posted on the another forum what I saw on some japanese sites reporting about the Digital Director being able to disable filters entirely, essentially making the MSB a NOS DAC.

Hope @Daniel Gullman or someone from MSB can verify this? If true, would be interesting for HQplayer users.
Click to expand...

Yes, this is an interesting development and news to me. If the internal filters can be disabled and the MSB dacs can be used in NOS mode then they could be used and their owners could make use of HQPLAYER. Looking forward to @Daniel Gullman confirming if this is indeed the case.
 
  • Like
Reactions: shawnf
Carlos269 said:
Seasonic Prime Ultra Platinum switching power supply.
Click to expand...
I have this one as well. It’s close to linear psu
one thing in toying of the years is this
on a Linux os be it nas or server the psu is much less important
on a nas it’s almost impossible
On a server it more obvious
another thing I do is use a separate psu to spin the disks alone
and a linaer just for the 5 volts of the Drives
These two methods help to use a linear psu
I have a few dacs that have Nos settings , maybe I need to try again as I don’t like them in nos
I’ll post the models shortly and will be happy on advice please
 
shawnf said:
I posted on another forum what I saw on some japanese sites reporting about the Digital Director being able to disable filters entirely, essentially making the MSB a NOS DAC.

Hope @Daniel Gullman or someone from MSB can verify this? If true, would be interesting for HQplayer users.
Click to expand...
Hey there Shawn. The digital processing of the Digital Director can be turned off to pass bit perfect files directly to the DAC unit. We use music files for code updates and this is the only way to get them there without corrupting the data. The DAC will still process the data with onboard digital filters when the digital director is shut down, so I fear this won't suit this application.
Carlos269 said:
Yes, this is an interesting development and news to me. If the internal filters can be disabled and the MSB dacs can be used in NOS mode then they could be used and their owners could make use of HQPLAYER. Looking forward to @Daniel Gullman confirming if this is indeed the case.
Click to expand...
See above.
 
  • Like
Reactions: shawnf and Carlos269
Also convolution rendering in HQPlayer is excellent and better than doing it in Roon.
 
Carlos269 said:
Lately there have been a number of posts once again reigniting the endless debates of analog versus digital. There was also a new crop of digital devices that debuted at the Munich show this year. All those topics are subjects for debates. But what I don’t believe can be debated, but we shall see, is that high-rate DSD512x48 and DSD1024x48 with HQPLAYER 5 is the current cutting edge of digital playback. If someone wants to know how good digital playback can be at this time, and in the foreseeable future, one must look no further than HQPLAYER 5 outputting DSD512x48 or DSD1024x48 to a chipless DSD digital to analog converter. It gets no better than this, the issue is that very few have heard it or had a chance to compare it.

I would venture to say that very few people on this forum have heard HQPLAYER outputting DSD512x48 or DSD1024x48 to a chipless DSD digital to analog converter.

Who on this forum, other than myself, has heard HQPLAYER outputting DSD512x48 or DSD1024x48 to a chipless DSD digital to analog converter?

The Halo May counts but more interesting would be comments from those that have heard it the T+A DAC200 or T+A SD 3100 HV Reference streaming DAC.

I currently have four DAC’s that can process native DSD512x48 or higher rates from HQPLAYER, which has allowed me to form this opinion.

Welcome any comments from those who have heard HQPLAYER outputting DSD512x48 or DSD1024x48 to a chipless DSD digital to analog converter, and how it compares to the WADAX, dCS, MSB and Aries Cerat playback quality. These dacs I believe are all limited to DSD256. The LampizatOr Horizon can playback DSD512 but it is my understanding that details for the off the shelf dac IC chip solution used have not been disclosed or any details to refute the use of an off the shelf IC chip dac have not been forthcoming.
Click to expand...
Decided to post this here. I have a Sony TAZH1ES DAC which uses Sony's own FPGA chip capable of processing DSD up to 11024 X 48. I am using a Zidoo media player as a streamer and this is my first toe in the DSD waters. I want to curate a nice collection of files I can purchase through various download services.
So, is HQPLAYER have an advantage over other players when it comes to DSD?
Is there a service that sells DSD files in a collection/playlist format? I built my movie collection buying sets of blu-rays that were curated by the studios. Thanks
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

H
ECDesigns' powerDAC-SX: a new way of driving your speakers and headphones
Replies
23
Views
3K
General Audio Forum
hopkins
H
J
DSP, analogue or IC volume control for 2.1 system?
Replies
0
Views
390
Power Amplifiers and Preamplifiers Forum
jimbobcardiff
J
S
Transports: MSB Select vs Wadax
Replies
1
Views
1K
Digital Audio Forum: DAC, Transports, Digital Processing Forum
roundhead
R
C
Charles S System
Replies
11
Views
1K
Members' Systems
Charles S
C
latestyle
ADC recommendation?
Replies
19
Views
2K
Digital Audio Forum: DAC, Transports, Digital Processing Forum
audiobomber
audiobomber

About us

  • What’s Best Forum is THE forum for high end audio, product reviews, advice and sharing experiences on the best of everything else. This is THE place where audiophiles and audio companies discuss vintage, contemporary and new audio products, music servers, music streamers, computer audio, digital-to-analog converters, turntables, phono stages, cartridges, reel-to-reel tape machines, speakers, headphones and tube and solid-state amplification. Founded in 2010 What’s Best Forum invites intelligent and courteous people of all interests and backgrounds to describe and discuss the best of everything. From beginners to life-long hobbyists to industry professionals, we enjoy learning about new things and meeting new people, and participating in spirited debates.

Quick Navigation

Home Forums

User Menu

Login
Top Bottom