How to ID true Koetsu Black made by Mr. Sugano, the father?

DaveP

New Member
Oct 18, 2018
3
1
1
66
Interesting thread worthy of reference, thus adding my 2 cents worth. Bought in 1983 and retipped by vd Hul.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_2451e.jpg
    IMG_2451e.jpg
    22.7 KB · Views: 33
  • IMG_2454.JPG
    IMG_2454.JPG
    2.9 MB · Views: 39
  • Like
Reactions: jadis

new2Krell

Well-Known Member
Feb 9, 2020
67
60
85
Some photos of yet another iteration of the Black. I bought this one new in the early nineties, it seems to be between the earlier Musashino 80's version and the later Goldline. Still has the black underside of the 80's version, but with the bevelled edges of the later Goldline.
Also noted, the serial number is quite different (lower) than ones already shown here, suggesting definitely a different series to the Musashino labelled carts.
Curiously, the box has a label on it from the Distributor (Friden Trading) stating "Black Mk III".
 

Attachments

  • Koetsu 1.JPG
    Koetsu 1.JPG
    677.3 KB · Views: 8
  • Koetsu 2.JPG
    Koetsu 2.JPG
    684.5 KB · Views: 9
  • Koetsu 3.JPG
    Koetsu 3.JPG
    794.9 KB · Views: 9
  • Koetsu 4.JPG
    Koetsu 4.JPG
    500.8 KB · Views: 10

crosswind

Well-Known Member
Jun 6, 2021
75
151
98
45
Svartskog, Greater Oslo, Norway
Mine seems to be identical to yours new2krell, besides the serial number obviously. Mine has #12321 and Japan written on it.

I bought this for 50 bucks a few years ago, without the diamond tip. It came back to me last winter, from anamightysound, being fully overhauled and plays really good in my FR64s arm. The previous owner told me it was bought in the eighties and had been stored in a drawer for many many years.

8806E361-8168-4673-A569-01E579FF7952.jpeg BB69CD18-5FA9-4708-806D-DBCC920B5DED.jpeg D10C99A7-7FB9-4437-80CC-53D7A7F1D91F.jpeg
 
  • Like
Reactions: RickS

new2Krell

Well-Known Member
Feb 9, 2020
67
60
85
Mine seems to be identical to yours
It does indeed. The same series for sure, I'd say. It would be nice to understand the sequencing and the differences.
If this particular version is a MkIII, there was presumably another version between this and the Musashino labelled carts pictured in the thread (unless there were two versions of the Musashino). Does that also make the Goldline (with the gold bottom plate) a MKIV, I wonder? I am sure someone somewhere knows.
No matter what, great cartridges in my opinion. I thoroughly enjoy mine. Vocals are really something else.
 
  • Like
Reactions: crosswind

new2Krell

Well-Known Member
Feb 9, 2020
67
60
85
I hope this helps!
Had a bit of spare time this am, went searching and found some interesting info on Blacks. I can't verify the accuracy, but it does at least seem to tie in with photos and details here quite well. I will leave it up to individuals to decide validity:

It appears there were two versions of the all black Musashino cart.

1980 Koetsu Black (all black, screw on front face). 9.9g (or 9.5). Musashino on top. s/n 50xxx.
1982 Koetsu Black mk 2 (all black). Musashino. s/n 527xx. 11.2g.
1985 Koetsu Black Goldline 12.1g. Black with gold trim sn 1xxxxx.
Koetsu Black Goldline mk 2 Gold bottom and gold trim. 10.8g

Crosswind and my carts are, as thought, a different series and would appear to be the first "Goldline". Not mentioned here to be MKIII though, as per the distributors label on my Black's box.
Assuming these first Goldlines to be MKIII's, I think it's reasonable to also call the gold bottomed Goldline a Black MKIV (or Goldline MKII). Due to weights quoted, there clearly seems to be a difference between these two.
Jadis and RickS, it appears you have a MKII
DaveP and msm-1, it appears you have MKIs (can't see if there is a screw on the front face from pics - would increase validation of info if there).

Info found on vinylengine, for the record. There are also some photos of the MKI and MkII external and internals (clearly a difference inside - didn't want to post the pics here in case of infringement).
A comment also suggests the internals of the MKII are very similar to the MKIII, but no pics of the III to compare - and no, just in case you are thinking, I am not going to undo mine and take one! :)
 

jadis

Well-Known Member
Apr 28, 2010
12,361
5,471
2,810
Manila, Philippines
I hope this helps!
Had a bit of spare time this am, went searching and found some interesting info on Blacks. I can't verify the accuracy, but it does at least seem to tie in with photos and details here quite well. I will leave it up to individuals to decide validity:

It appears there were two versions of the all black Musashino cart.

1980 Koetsu Black (all black, screw on front face). 9.9g (or 9.5). Musashino on top. s/n 50xxx.
1982 Koetsu Black mk 2 (all black). Musashino. s/n 527xx. 11.2g.
1985 Koetsu Black Goldline 12.1g. Black with gold trim sn 1xxxxx.
Koetsu Black Goldline mk 2 Gold bottom and gold trim. 10.8g

Crosswind and my carts are, as thought, a different series and would appear to be the first "Goldline". Not mentioned here to be MKIII though, as per the distributors label on my Black's box.
Assuming these first Goldlines to be MKIII's, I think it's reasonable to also call the gold bottomed Goldline a Black MKIV (or Goldline MKII). Due to weights quoted, there clearly seems to be a difference between these two.
Jadis and RickS, it appears you have a MKII
DaveP and msm-1, it appears you have MKIs (can't see if there is a screw on the front face from pics - would increase validation of info if there).

Info found on vinylengine, for the record. There are also some photos of the MKI and MkII external and internals (clearly a difference inside - didn't want to post the pics here in case of infringement).
A comment also suggests the internals of the MKII are very similar to the MKIII, but no pics of the III to compare - and no, just in case you are thinking, I am not going to undo mine and take one! :)
Great info! Thanks for letting us know, new2Krell.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RickS

jadis

Well-Known Member
Apr 28, 2010
12,361
5,471
2,810
Manila, Philippines
Interesting too, to know the MkII weighs a bit more at 11.2g, That is very near the weight of the platinum models. Would you know what magnet these Blacks used? I heard it may be alnico.
 

mtemur

Well-Known Member
Mar 26, 2019
1,351
1,312
245
48
Finding an old Koetsu Black is hard and finding one in good condition is almost impossible IMHO. Cartridge suspensions are more or less like car tires, they deteriorate over time. When it’s replaced whole sound signature of cartridge changes. Suspension is probably the most significant element that gives a cartridge it’s distinctive sound signature. IMHO old Koetsu Black cartridges from 80’s need a suspension replacement and some need a complete rebuild including coils, cantilever and stylus. I think all materials that are used by Koetsu now is different than 80’s. It looks like a remote possibility to resurrect a Koetsu Black from 80’s with it’s original sound even it’s rebuild by Koetsu. It can be better or worse but I don’t think it will be the same as original. Not to mention the differences if it’s rebuild in somewhere else.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RickS and jadis

new2Krell

Well-Known Member
Feb 9, 2020
67
60
85
Interesting too, to know the MkII weighs a bit more at 11.2g, That is very near the weight of the platinum models. Would you know what magnet these Blacks used? I heard it may be alnico.
Sorry, no info on actual materials used. I guess there has to remain some mystery to the Koetsu magic :)
The only other comment I could make on what I found is perahps the suggestion that after Musashino, production MAY have moved to Dynavector, not least because Koetsus were then marketed through Dynavector dealers, apparently, after 1985. This is not my suggestion, just repeating what I read.
It would certainly follow in my case, if true. When I bought my Black in the early 90's it was direct from the Dynavector distributor who was also the Koetsu distributor at the time.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jadis

new2Krell

Well-Known Member
Feb 9, 2020
67
60
85
Finding an old Koetsu Black is hard and finding one in good condition is almost impossible IMHO. Cartridge suspensions are more or less like car tires, they deteriorate over time. When it’s replaced whole sound signature of cartridge changes. Suspension is probably the most significant element that gives a cartridge it’s distinctive sound signature. IMHO old Koetsu Black cartridges from 80’s need a suspension replacement and some need a complete rebuild including coils, cantilever and stylus. I think all materials that are used by Koetsu now is different than 80’s. It looks like a remote possibility to resurrect a Koetsu Black from 80’s with it’s original sound even it’s rebuild by Koetsu. It can be better or worse but I don’t think it will be the same as original. Not to mention the differences if it’s rebuild in somewhere else.
There is a lot of logic in your comments. I have known mine since new and it has had fair, but not excessive, use during this time. I still enjoy it immensly, but I am very much aware it will not last forever and am starting to consider what I am going to do when it is no longer so enjoyable.
The cost of a new Black (or rebuild) has become quite an investment, but what alternatives are there? I don't know yet, but it may well be if I want to continue to enjoy what I have become accustomed to as the "Koetsu sound", I will simply need to pay the money and replace it with another one.

Almost certainly a Koetsu rebuild of the MKI will sound different, I think, not least because of the differences internally. The MKII perhaps slightly less so, and the MKIII maybe even less so as they appear to be more similar and possibly closer to the curent version, but I don't know for sure. If I should ever get mine rebuilt, or replaced with new, I will let you know what I find.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RickS and mtemur

RickS

Well-Known Member
May 23, 2018
64
93
123
NW Indiana
Almost 3 years after finding my Koetsu Black, it stubbornly keeps playing as good as the day I installed it. It now has great sentimental value especially since it came from a good friend of mine. So I would lean heavily towards a Koetsu rebuild, however they would chose to do it rather than trade up.
What I have decided is to snag either a new Rosewood or Rosewood Signature or the latest Black Goldline before I send this one off. Gots to keep that first Koetsu like I’m keeping my first and probably only Rolex lol.
 
  • Like
Reactions: new2Krell and jadis

Bill Hart

Well-Known Member
May 11, 2012
2,683
174
1,150
Will Koetsu rebuild a black that was purchased used overseas for an American customer? There is at least one Far East dealer that seems to have a raft of old Koetsus that need work- missing cantilevers, etc. I don't know if it makes financial sense to revive one of these old ones-
I have two modern Koetsu stones that came from the authorized US distributor, and given the price of these cartridges today, having the factory rebuild them seems like a prudent outlay, compared to the cost of a new cartridge in the same league. But I had the impression the factory would not work on gray market cartridges.
On history gathering, Although Ana Mighty has been around for only 13 or so years, they might be able to put together a timeline for these things based on rebuilding/retipping them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jadis

jadis

Well-Known Member
Apr 28, 2010
12,361
5,471
2,810
Manila, Philippines
Will Koetsu rebuild a black that was purchased used overseas for an American customer? There is at least one Far East dealer that seems to have a raft of old Koetsus that need work- missing cantilevers, etc. I don't know if it makes financial sense to revive one of these old ones-
I have two modern Koetsu stones that came from the authorized US distributor, and given the price of these cartridges today, having the factory rebuild them seems like a prudent outlay, compared to the cost of a new cartridge in the same league. But I had the impression the factory would not work on gray market cartridges.
On history gathering, Although Ana Mighty has been around for only 13 or so years, they might be able to put together a timeline for these things based on rebuilding/retipping them.
I believe Koetsu will first check the serial number of any unit that comes its way for rebuilding, and they should service it. The cost of rebuild though for a Black or Rosewood would not be economically pleasing, as you can find a good priced brand new one from a reliable source.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RickS and Bill Hart

About us

  • What’s Best Forum is THE forum for high end audio, product reviews, advice and sharing experiences on the best of everything else. This is THE place where audiophiles and audio companies discuss vintage, contemporary and new audio products, music servers, music streamers, computer audio, digital-to-analog converters, turntables, phono stages, cartridges, reel-to-reel tape machines, speakers, headphones and tube and solid-state amplification. Founded in 2010 What’s Best Forum invites intelligent and courteous people of all interests and backgrounds to describe and discuss the best of everything. From beginners to life-long hobbyists to industry professionals, we enjoy learning about new things and meeting new people, and participating in spirited debates.

Quick Navigation

User Menu

Steve Williams
Site Founder | Site Owner | Administrator
Ron Resnick
Site Co-Owner | Administrator
Julian (The Fixer)
Website Build | Marketing Managersing