Merrill Element 116 audition in Hong Kong - A New Era of ClassD

QuadDiffuser

VIP/Donor
Apr 2, 2017
376
343
340
Hong Kong
Apologies, everyone; I had neglected to post my observations after my home audition of the Merrill Element 116 and AGD Vivace mono-block amplifiers. Very likely, I did not want to publicly post the results because they were disappointing, and I didn't want my humble opinions to inflict pain and negatively impact (and even magnify) the interests of all concerned via the Internet. Although nearly one year has passed, I allowed the amps to "warm up" extensively, and took extremely detailed notes on their aural characteristics, using a variety of music which I was intimately familiar with.

Suffice it to say that in MY system, the 116s sounded "broken", with a serious lack of high frequency energy and resolution - so much so that my auditions stopped early. Perhaps its settings for attack/decay were not set properly (see previous post)?

The AGD Vivace amps captivated my visual and tactile senses deeply, as they were SO beautiful to look at. Unfortunately, its single pair of speaker binding posts did not accommodate my double pair of bi-wired speaker cables sufficiently solidly, and their high frequency extension and resolution were moderately lacking, robbing music of their excitement and verve. My conclusion is that there was something inherently limiting with Class D amps, even with designs utilizing the latest hyper-fast GaN semiconductor circuits. If my JRDG 725S2 amplifiers were the reference, assigning it a relative score of 95% [ a composite score of sonics (80%) and ergonomics/usability (20%) ], the 116s scored only 60% (far short of even the minimum required for ownership and musical enjoyment), while the AGDs scored 80% (good, but short of being great).
 
  • Like
Reactions: wjt3 and analogsa

ihmeyers

VIP/Donor
Nov 13, 2017
262
193
325
Palm Beach County, Florida
Mine sound great AFTER I adjusted the attack/decay settings to Smooth. Meanwhile, people are gaslighting me on this saying (not on this board) either that there are no settings (I have photos) or that they don't do anything and I am experiencing "cognitive bias." Merrill didn't return either of two e-mails or a voicemail message I left so I don't know what the official position is.

Maybe I am, but I have been an audiophile for the past 45 years and have been seriously into high-end since I could first afford that in my thirties. I can hear the difference between resistors or caps of different brands when they are changed out in a circuit. I'm sure most, if not all on this board can do the same. In my system, the 116 was bright and too forward on "Fast" setting with limited lateral spread. It sounds completely different on Smooth Attack / Smooth Decay; open, fast but not etched with good L-R and front-back imaging in my much less than ideal room.

Then again maybe that's just my subjective reality and all those settings really do sound the same similar to how all cables sound alike and all digital sounds alike, since it's just zeros and ones after all. ;)
 
Last edited:

wjt3

Well-Known Member
Mar 8, 2020
2
0
66
55
Hi all-- I had the AGD Vivace for about a month and asked Al for a pair of Gran Vivace. Boom-- locked in and keepers. Vivace was good- but the GV is now where I'd like to stay. Try Vivace first- it may be all one needs for their equipment and tastes-=- just sayin...
 

Addicted to hifi

VIP/Donor
Sep 8, 2020
4,610
2,039
265
52
Australia
Class D amplifiers were often being looked down on in the past, until when better designs such as nCore, IceEdge emerged these several years.
Even so, most of audiophiles in Hong Kong still prefer conventional Class A or AB amplifiers.
They stereotype Class D as more suitable for entry- or at most mid-grade audio systems.

New hopes have appeared in 2018.
The Nuprime Evolution One mono poweramps received praises in diff countries.
https://www.hifi-advice.com/blog/review/analog-reviews/amplifier-reviews/nuprime-evolution-one/
https://sonicunity.com/pages/the-nuprime-evo-one-review-first-listening-session
https://review.u-audio.com.tw/reviewdetail.asp?reviewid=1542


And the ClassD guru Bruno Putzeys has a new venture : Purifi.
https://www.purifi-audio.com/
https://6moons.com/audioreview_articles/purifi/
https://www.miveraaudio.com/forum/the-puremusic-family/testing-the-new-purifi-1et400a-amplifier-modules
Preliminary assessment is very good but is their collaboration with NAD aiming at mid or hi-end market?

Nuprime Evolution One and Purifi can be considered to be evolutary types of products.
What I am more interested in is the application of Gallium Nitride power transistors in audio amplifiers.
Technics, AGD Productions & Merrill Audio have launched amps using this new class of transistors last year.
WBF members can do a google search for the press reviews on them.

Last Saturday, I was able to audition the Merrill Element 116 mono poweramps in an home environment in Hong Kong!
They are paired with Antipodes DX server, Lampizator Pacific DAC, Emia full-balanced silver autoformer passive preamp and Verity Audio Sarastro IIS speakers.
View attachment 54770

My friend David's previous monos are MBL Corona. They are based on modified nCore modules of Bruno Putzeys.
View attachment 54771

The Element 116 is very well and nicely built. The external design/look is excellent. The chassis is made of mirror/reflective steel plate with gold colour metal blocks for ?vibration modulation. The original footers are GAIA III Footers of IsoAcoustics :
View attachment 54772
View attachment 54773

The connectors are also of high quality : from Furutech & WBT:
View attachment 54774

We listened for 3 hours and were very surprised by the sonic characters of the Element 116.
Before the audition we expected that the fast Gallium Nitride would make a fast/dynamical amp with very extended freq range. In simple words - a very HiFish amp.
On the contrary the truth is that Element 116 doesn't have any traits of the older generations of ClassD amps.
It's actually extremely musical : fast and dynamical but warm and rich.
There wasn't any mechanicalness in the midrange & treble. They were smooth and continuous.
The bass was deep and articulate/fast. The Sarastro IIS speakers were under its complete control.
The soundstage was wide & deep and images within were stable and real-like.

All in all the Element 116 bettered the MBL Corona monos in all sonic aspects.
IMHO it can challenge hi-end conventional class A and class AB poweramps with prices several times higher.
The cost/performance ratio is impeccable!

i opine that Gallium Nitride power transistors has brought about a bright future and a new era for audio amps.
I have plan to upgrade my poweramps later this year or in early 2020.
Merrill Element Series will be a top choice of mine for sure!
:D:D:D
very nice.
 

The Knife

Well-Known Member
Nov 13, 2020
141
104
115
Stockholm, Sweden
Class D amplifiers were often being looked down on in the past, until when better designs such as nCore, IceEdge emerged these several years.
Even so, most of audiophiles in Hong Kong still prefer conventional Class A or AB amplifiers.
They stereotype Class D as more suitable for entry- or at most mid-grade audio systems.

New hopes have appeared in 2018.
The Nuprime Evolution One mono poweramps received praises in diff countries.
https://www.hifi-advice.com/blog/review/analog-reviews/amplifier-reviews/nuprime-evolution-one/
https://sonicunity.com/pages/the-nuprime-evo-one-review-first-listening-session
https://review.u-audio.com.tw/reviewdetail.asp?reviewid=1542


And the ClassD guru Bruno Putzeys has a new venture : Purifi.
https://www.purifi-audio.com/
https://6moons.com/audioreview_articles/purifi/
https://www.miveraaudio.com/forum/the-puremusic-family/testing-the-new-purifi-1et400a-amplifier-modules
Preliminary assessment is very good but is their collaboration with NAD aiming at mid or hi-end market?

Nuprime Evolution One and Purifi can be considered to be evolutary types of products.
What I am more interested in is the application of Gallium Nitride power transistors in audio amplifiers.
Technics, AGD Productions & Merrill Audio have launched amps using this new class of transistors last year.
WBF members can do a google search for the press reviews on them.

Last Saturday, I was able to audition the Merrill Element 116 mono poweramps in an home environment in Hong Kong!
They are paired with Antipodes DX server, Lampizator Pacific DAC, Emia full-balanced silver autoformer passive preamp and Verity Audio Sarastro IIS speakers.
View attachment 54770

My friend David's previous monos are MBL Corona. They are based on modified nCore modules of Bruno Putzeys.
View attachment 54771

The Element 116 is very well and nicely built. The external design/look is excellent. The chassis is made of mirror/reflective steel plate with gold colour metal blocks for ?vibration modulation. The original footers are GAIA III Footers of IsoAcoustics :
View attachment 54772
View attachment 54773

The connectors are also of high quality : from Furutech & WBT:
View attachment 54774

We listened for 3 hours and were very surprised by the sonic characters of the Element 116.
Before the audition we expected that the fast Gallium Nitride would make a fast/dynamical amp with very extended freq range. In simple words - a very HiFish amp.
On the contrary the truth is that Element 116 doesn't have any traits of the older generations of ClassD amps.
It's actually extremely musical : fast and dynamical but warm and rich.
There wasn't any mechanicalness in the midrange & treble. They were smooth and continuous.
The bass was deep and articulate/fast. The Sarastro IIS speakers were under its complete control.
The soundstage was wide & deep and images within were stable and real-like.

All in all the Element 116 bettered the MBL Corona monos in all sonic aspects.
IMHO it can challenge hi-end conventional class A and class AB poweramps with prices several times higher.
The cost/performance ratio is impeccable!

i opine that Gallium Nitride power transistors has brought about a bright future and a new era for audio amps.
I have plan to upgrade my poweramps later this year or in early 2020.
Merrill Element Series will be a top choice of mine for sure!
:D:D:D
Dear CKKeung. Thanks for sharing. It seems we both share the fascination for the latest D-GaN-fet amplifiers. We also both share the passion for Hong Kong . I lived on the HK-Island for three absolutely beautiful years :). Best Regards from Stockholm
 
  • Like
Reactions: CKKeung

About us

  • What’s Best Forum is THE forum for high end audio, product reviews, advice and sharing experiences on the best of everything else. This is THE place where audiophiles and audio companies discuss vintage, contemporary and new audio products, music servers, music streamers, computer audio, digital-to-analog converters, turntables, phono stages, cartridges, reel-to-reel tape machines, speakers, headphones and tube and solid-state amplification. Founded in 2010 What’s Best Forum invites intelligent and courteous people of all interests and backgrounds to describe and discuss the best of everything. From beginners to life-long hobbyists to industry professionals, we enjoy learning about new things and meeting new people, and participating in spirited debates.

Quick Navigation

User Menu

Steve Williams
Site Founder | Site Owner | Administrator
Ron Resnick
Site Co-Owner | Administrator
Julian (The Fixer)
Website Build | Marketing Managersing