I won't comment on the review or the back and forth with Andre and Mep. As Andre mentioned having some designers chime in about volume controls, I thought I would post my opinion on this subject.
I design the Purity Audio Design product line which consist mostly of preamps. Over the years of R&D for this line, a lot of testing went into volume controls and their impact on the sound. In a nutshell, they are critical. There are many good and bad examples available to manufactures but much of this will be determined by price points and features one looks for. Our upper end models utilize autoformer attenuation as well as custom designed "secondary" autoformers for output gain versatility in a very unique implementation.
Other features we looked for in our input stage was the ability to have phase reversal which I believe is important in today's equipment as well as ballanced inputs and full remote capability.
In the end, the autoformer based volume and secondary gain setting system proved to be an exceptional route and provided one of the purest signal paths without sonic degradation as well as a host of features we were looking for. Granted there are other very good options out there and I will not get into debates of what is the best as there will be too many opinions.
A debate is an argument with no possibility of a winner.
I design the Purity Audio Design product line which consist mostly of preamps. Over the years of R&D for this line, a lot of testing went into volume controls and their impact on the sound. In a nutshell, they are critical. There are many good and bad examples available to manufactures but much of this will be determined by price points and features one looks for. Our upper end models utilize autoformer attenuation as well as custom designed "secondary" autoformers for output gain versatility in a very unique implementation.
Other features we looked for in our input stage was the ability to have phase reversal which I believe is important in today's equipment as well as ballanced inputs and full remote capability.
In the end, the autoformer based volume and secondary gain setting system proved to be an exceptional route and provided one of the purest signal paths without sonic degradation as well as a host of features we were looking for. Granted there are other very good options out there and I will not get into debates of what is the best as there will be too many opinions.
A debate is an argument with no possibility of a winner.