To Roon or Not to Roon?

Juiced

Juiced

Active Member
Nov 26, 2022
80
108
40
38
I was wondering if I should renew my Roon yearly subscription, as I'm only playing Tidal with it.

I've got a Weiss 501 DAC/Steamer that is "Roon Ready" certified, but it also has DLNA and a USB port.

+ From my Windows PC, I can play Tidal via USB cable with Tidal Software with "Exclusive Mode" enabled, playing up to 192/24 hires.
+ From my Android phone, I can stream Tidal via DLNA with the BubbleUPnP app, streaming up to 192/24 hires.

- I'm not using any of the Roon DSP features.
- I'm not caring for any of Roon's media management capabilities.

What matters to me is audio fidelity, which, from my experience, Roon doesn't improve much if at all.
 
Juiced said:
- I'm not using any of the Roon DSP features.
- I'm not caring for any of Roon's media management capabilities.

What matters to me is audio fidelity, which, from my experience, Roon doesn't improve much if at all.
Click to expand...
Sounds like you’ve answered your own question.
I’m not hearing any reason for you to use Roon.

As an aside, I started using Roon primarily for the DSP features. But with time, I actually started really enjoying Roon’s media management capabilities.
 
  • Like
Reactions: christoph and Juiced
Yeah, Roon isn't audio fidelity champ. I use it, like it for background music. I use other software for critical listening...
 
The strongest selling point of Roon, for me at least, is the process of musical discovery via its “radio” feature.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rameshtgo, lupoal, PYP and 1 other person
Young Skywalker said:
The strongest selling point of Roon, for me at least, is the process of musical discovery via its “radio” feature.
Click to expand...
The same feature exist in tidal.

I do love the "Composer" feature in Roon,
great way to discover covers and songs in a verity of genres.
 
  • Like
Reactions: christoph and Young Skywalker
Juiced said:
- I'm not using any of the Roon DSP features.
- I'm not caring for any of Roon's media management capabilities.

What matters to me is audio fidelity, which, from my experience, Roon doesn't improve much if at all.
Click to expand...
Seems like you're not really using Roon.

Roon sounds fine to me. Personally I wouldn't trust anyone else's opinion about how it sounds.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Daverich4, PYP and Young Skywalker
denydog said:
Seems like you're not really using Roon.

Roon sounds fine to me. Personally I wouldn't trust anyone else's opinion about how it sounds.
Click to expand...
Agreed. I don’t have any issue with the sonic presentation from Roon. I am not hearing things and thinking, “OMG, that sounds harsh/bright/lifeless/opaque/etc.” If the sonic differences between using Roon software or some alternative software solution are as great as some make out then something must be broken with one or more offerings or their implementation. They have a very well defined objective with very well known technical issues. Galvanic isolation (breaking the electrical ground plane) of the conduit for data packets ought to be an end game solution. If it is not, then we ought to be seeking scientific evidence that the perceived differences aren’t simply imagined. I know, I know… trust your ears and all that. But there are many instances where we can’t trust our ears for the psychology aspect makes this very fallible in an analytical sense. By all means trust your ears when it comes to what is pleasing to one’s self but don’t use this as a method of proclaiming absolutes, e.g., Roon sounds poorly.

I contend that the distortions in the frequency, phase and time domain as a result of a loudspeaker’s interactions with the listening environment are orders of magnitude greater than any perceptible sonic difference between any two power cables, equipment racks, streaming software solutions, footers, etc. Address the gross issues before engaging in audiophilia nervosa.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lupoal, Mgperdices and Townes
Young Skywalker said:
Agreed. I don’t have any issue with the sonic presentation from Roon. I am not hearing things and thinking, “OMG, that sounds harsh/bright/lifeless/opaque/etc.” If the sonic differences between using Roon software or some alternative software solution are as great as some make out then something must be broken with one or more offerings or their implementation. They have a very well defined objective with very well known technical issues. Galvanic isolation (breaking the electrical ground plane) of the conduit for data packets ought to be an end game solution. If it is not, then we ought to be seeking scientific evidence that the perceived differences aren’t simply imagined. I know, I know… trust your ears and all that. But there are many instances where we can’t trust our ears for the psychology aspect makes this very fallible in an analytical sense. By all means trust your ears when it comes to what is pleasing to one’s self but don’t use this as a method of proclaiming absolutes, e.g., Roon sounds poorly.

I contend that the distortions in the frequency, phase and time domain as a result of a loudspeaker’s interactions with the listening environment are orders of magnitude greater than any perceptible sonic difference between any two power cables, equipment racks, streaming software solutions, footers, etc. Address the gross issues before engaging in audiophilia nervosa.
Click to expand...
Would be interesting if a small group of listeners tried two (or more) streamers with Roon to determine if implementation within the streamer itself (use exact setup except for streamer) is the reason Roon can sound good to some and not good to others. If those same streamers could use different control software, that would be a good test as well. Given how many variables there are in streaming, it would seem impossible to predict how any control software/streamer will sound until one tests it.

I use Roon all the time and find it can sound very good, especially with 24 bit files. That was true with a Mola Mola Tambaqui as the endpoint as long as copper ethernet cleaners were used, or the Grimm MU1 with the MMT and especially with the Grimm MU2 streamer/upsampler/DAC. Grimm is working on a software update so that the MU1 and MU2 will be able to use JPLAY and Audirvana too. That will make for an interesting comparison of control software.

Qobuz implemented within Roon is a great music discovery tool.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Delkat and Young Skywalker
denydog said:
Seems like you're not really using Roon.

Roon sounds fine to me. Personally I wouldn't trust anyone else's opinion about how it sounds.
Click to expand...
Roon is all i use but just for Tidal playback :)

I do love some of its media management features, but it's not worth the extra money for me.

So I was wondering if I should save myself the $150 for the yearly subscription and just switch to the Tidal software.

As for my ears, Roon doesn't improve Tidal SQ and just sounds pretty much the same.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: denydog
Juiced said:
Roon is all i use but just for Tidal playback :)

I do love some of its media management features, but it's not worth the extra money for me.

So I was wondering if I should save myself the $150 for the yearly subscription and just switch to the Tidal software.

As for my ears, Roon doesn't improve Tidal SQ and just sounds pretty much the same.
Click to expand...
It sounds as though you could do without Roon, so it is probably best to cancel your Roon subscription and just use the Tidal software. If you find that you miss some of the functionality of Roon, you can always take out another Roon subscription. Good luck.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PYP and Juiced
Stefan said:
That is precisely my sentiment and way of using Roon.
Click to expand...
What is your music Player of choice for Sound quality reasons?
 
jfrech said:
Yeah, Roon isn't audio fidelity champ. I use it, like it for background music. I use other software for critical listening...
Click to expand...
What software do you listen with?
 
PYP said:
Would be interesting if a small group of listeners tried two (or more) streamers with Roon to determine if implementation within the streamer itself (use exact setup except for streamer) is the reason Roon can sound good to some and not good to others. If those same streamers could use different control software, that would be a good test as well. Given how many variables there are in streaming, it would seem impossible to predict how any control software/streamer will sound until one tests it.

I use Roon all the time and find it can sound very good, especially with 24 bit files. That was true with a Mola Mola Tambaqui as the endpoint as long as copper ethernet cleaners were used, or the Grimm MU1 with the MMT and especially with the Grimm MU2 streamer/upsampler/DAC. Grimm is working on a software update so that the MU1 and MU2 will be able to use JPLAY and Audirvana too. That will make for an interesting comparison of control software.

Qobuz implemented within Roon is a great music discovery tool.
Click to expand...
I did a test with my Bricasti M5 streamer (into an Audio Note DAC 0.1x).
Comparison was between:
- Roon server (Mac Mini M2) with M5 as Roon renderer
- JPlay app driving M5 via UPNP
And... they didn't sound the same way.
With JPlay the sound is more detailed, more "HiFi", you feel like you're hearing more things, and there is a sense of more cleanliness. I understand why many people would prefer JPlay compared to Roon.
But I still prefer Roon SQ cause, with JPlay, I feel that some "body" is lost to advantage those high frequency details.
To me, Roon has a more balanced and natural sound, even if it comes at the expense of... the last drop of detail.
By the way, I don't use Roon DSP or any other sound characterization feature. I use it just because it's the best interface in the market by a far margin and because its Radio feature lets me discover lots of new music (I know, some other software implemented a similar function but, in my experience, Roon Radio works much better than the others).
 
  • Like
Reactions: MRJAZZ, PYP and Juiced
I've decided not to renew my Roon subscription.

Now I'm playing Tidal from my Windows PC, connected to the Weiss 501 via generic USB cable.

The odd thing, with the Tidal software I'm finding the bottom end to be more profound and punchier and overall Music to be more engaging.

VS. playing Tidal from Roon over the network via Ethernet cable and a switch hooked up to linear PSU.


Maybe i didn't do enough critical listening with the Tidal software..
 
  • Like
Reactions: ecwl and Mark212121
Juiced said:
I've decided not to renew my Roon subscription.

Now I'm playing Tidal from my Windows PC, connected to the Weiss 501 via generic USB cable.

The odd thing, with the Tidal software I'm finding the bottom end to be more profound and punchier and overall Music to be more engaging.

VS. playing Tidal from Roon over the network via Ethernet cable and a switch hooked up to linear PSU.


Maybe i didn't do enough critical listening with the Tidal software..
Click to expand...
I'm pleased that you are finding the Tidal software more than acceptable and more enjoyable than Roon. I assume you will make a decent saving by terminating your Roon subscription. Well done.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Juiced
Juiced said:
I was wondering if I should renew my Roon yearly subscription, as I'm only playing Tidal with it.

I've got a Weiss 501 DAC/Steamer that is "Roon Ready" certified, but it also has DLNA and a USB port.

+ From my Windows PC, I can play Tidal via USB cable with Tidal Software with "Exclusive Mode" enabled, playing up to 192/24 hires.
+ From my Android phone, I can stream Tidal via DLNA with the BubbleUPnP app, streaming up to 192/24 hires.

- I'm not using any of the Roon DSP features.
- I'm not caring for any of Roon's media management capabilities.

What matters to me is audio fidelity, which, from my experience, Roon doesn't improve much if at all.
Click to expand...
Hi.
Sound like you don`t have any use of Roon. For me the media management capabilities has opened a whole new world, learning about the the music, history, a.s.o. I have a big library, close to 80.000 tracks and for me Tidal has just made Roon better with HiRes alternatives to my librarys mostly 44.1 Mhz/16 bit rips (FLAC)
Thx.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Young Skywalker, PYP and Juiced
Juiced said:
I've decided not to renew my Roon subscription.

Now I'm playing Tidal from my Windows PC, connected to the Weiss 501 via generic USB cable.

The odd thing, with the Tidal software I'm finding the bottom end to be more profound and punchier and overall Music to be more engaging.

VS. playing Tidal from Roon over the network via Ethernet cable and a switch hooked up to linear PSU.


Maybe i didn't do enough critical listening with the Tidal software..
Click to expand...
I’m sure what you heard is correct. Different DACs have different USB and streamer (Roon Ready) implementation. This is why I don’t believe people can generalize in these situations.

A laptop running on batteries via USB into a DAC can sound better if the DAC can reject jitter and isolate the noise coming from the laptop.

When you have a computer sending signals through a switch to Roon streamer in the 501, there are more potential sources of noise even if those sources are generally theoretically lower in noise level. You can have noise from the Weiss 501 implementation of Roon Ready affecting the DAC. Even though your switch is connected to a linear PSU to prevent power supply RF ground noise from getting into the Weiss, everything upstream from the switch such as your cable modem/router’s power supply can still send their power supply RF ground noise through the Ethernet cables, passing through the switch into your DAC to affect the sound.

So if it sounds better to you and you’re happy, stick with what you like.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Juiced and PYP
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Juiced
Help from Metronome C6 & C6 signature owners with the m2tech USB card
Replies
0
Views
338
Digital Audio Forum: DAC, Transports, Digital Processing Forum
Juiced
Juiced
P
Playing local files with A8 much better than with Roon. How to fix?
Replies
16
Views
650
Digital Audio Forum: DAC, Transports, Digital Processing Forum
audiobomber
audiobomber
tmallin
Making Roon Sound Better
Replies
24
Views
4K
Tom's Corner Forum
tmallin
tmallin
Z
Help me replace my digital player/vault
Replies
5
Views
1K
Digital Audio Forum: DAC, Transports, Digital Processing Forum
Agent86
Agent86
J
No USB on Zen Stream in Roon Exclusive mode
Replies
4
Views
2K
Abbingdon Music Research / iFi audio
AMR / iFi audio
AMR / iFi audio

About us

  • What’s Best Forum is THE forum for high end audio, product reviews, advice and sharing experiences on the best of everything else. This is THE place where audiophiles and audio companies discuss vintage, contemporary and new audio products, music servers, music streamers, computer audio, digital-to-analog converters, turntables, phono stages, cartridges, reel-to-reel tape machines, speakers, headphones and tube and solid-state amplification. Founded in 2010 What’s Best Forum invites intelligent and courteous people of all interests and backgrounds to describe and discuss the best of everything. From beginners to life-long hobbyists to industry professionals, we enjoy learning about new things and meeting new people, and participating in spirited debates.

Quick Navigation

Home Forums

User Menu

Login
Top Bottom