It's been a week since my return from my LA trip, but came back sick, so hadn't had the chance to follow up on my visit to Steve's.
We spent a good two hours listening that day, starting with tape and then mostly LPs - with a brief CD review from his "pedestrian" Playback Designs player, as he calls it. Front and center was the ZYX and TechDas, with a quick switch to the Anna as mentioned earlier. The most critical aspect of the audition was using LPs that I also have, which made judgement easier to put together.
Scottish Fantasia on tape to kick it off: Dead quiet, great violin power, great imaging, great body
A variety of LPs followed, from Reference Recordings, Sheffield, and various reissues: I loved the Drum Record though I felt it was a little too "fat"; the RR Berlioz Fantastique had all the power I would expect; the Scheherazade... now that was really something... the power of the orchestra came all through, and the feeling was just incredible. This is the recording we used to A/B with the Anna, and again, no contest, the Anna was so polite and boring - we are done, let's go back to the ZYX. Amanda Mc Broom sounded REALLY wonderful, but I also thought perhaps a tad euphonic, not sure. For Duke was very real!
All of us being accustomed to our own system's sounds, we tend to immediately react to certain things we hear in someone else's system: in Steve's system case, it was a few things: the body of the sound, the incredible bass control and extension, coherence, quietness of the tape and especially the LPs, but at the same time, a little softening of the leading edge - common and consistent to both media. Frankly, I was expecting a little overblown and uncontrolled bass, but what I heard was extremely tight and extended - an incredible feat by those 30-watt Lamm amps. Dynamics were really good, but I think there is room for higher headroom - really curious to see what Steve's friend Marty achieves with these same speakers and the Spectral amps. I was also expecting tweeter issues - having heard them elsewhere - but not here; in fact, there was a lot of treble energy as I am used to at home, but at the same time, non-fatiguing or unnatural.
If I were to compare these Wilsons to, say, the Alexias I heard a few years ago driven by the Spectral 360s, I would say the differences were literally night and day. Whereas I simply hated the Alexia sound with its uncontrolled sound, full of seemingly fake reverb, and left the room after 20 (40?) minutes into the demo, I could spend a whole day listening to Steve's system. By contrast here, I loved the immediacy, something I am used to at home. And again, I loved the treble performance.
Orchestral body is something I've been fighting at home for the longest time; the room does not help, and the speakers just don't have the same size woofers. But after coming back, I increased my sub's cutover frequency with better results - but still not to Steve's system level.
This brings me to cut #2 we played: the Mahler #2 with Solti and the LSO. I am very familiar with it, but I still prefer my favorite BSO with Ozawa, and by a mile. Nonetheless, I am not aware of a recording that exactly does justice to the prescribed
instrumentation, especially the 6 on-stage timpani. The recording we played solidified my initial impression (from the Scottish Fantasia tape) of the elevated orchestral body, the depth of the soundstage, and especially the presence of the wind section - beautiful stuff. This LP reissue, for some reason, is "missing" an important aspect of the opening Allegro Maestoso, specifically the roughly 5 second span around the middle where the bass drum is played eeeeeeever to slightly solo. It's all there in the BSO/Philips recording but entirely missing in the LSO - either every system I've heard it on cannot resolve this very-low-level playing, or it's really missing... don't know. Nonetheless, overall, low level resolution was incredible - digital silence from the TechDas; I love this turntable. I tapped just about everywhere on it at the end, and the platter is dead quiet like the large piece of marble I have in my living room; what an incredible engineering feat this 'table is. Impressive, and lucky are those who can afford it.
Regarding the MB cables, Steve did have that long interconnect shown up above in place by the time I arrived, so I heard the latest. I can't tell what individual role they play in the system because I had not heard the system before, but they are obviously part of the excellent sound rendered. At the same time, none of us skeptics ever said anything about the sonics, we are only looking for real technical information. I did notice that the cables are squeezable, as if to absorb vibrations, which is good. The other thing I noticed with the Nordost (Valhalla???) interconnects from the Studer to the Doshi is how microphonic they are (just tapping them together or with my finger generated a sound); I had the same problem when I evaluated them in the phono section, and I would advise getting rid of them - they are apparently built to do that, as if feedback is welcome into the cable. Although I personally use the Valhalla tonearm wire, I would personally stop right there wrt Nordost.
Beautiful stuff, Steve, and thanks again for hosting us. The 2011 Barolo was equally stunning, and you probably know by now how much I love red wine!!!! Cheers to Cathy, and we hope to see you both back East!