Caught this one yesterday.
It was ok, good perhaps. But nothing I'd recommend seeing in theater.
It starts off with horribly mixed audio for at least 1/4 of the movie. There's dance scenes that are extremely under-captivating with the score and singing being nearly muted compared to what musicals usually have for volume. The instruments were out of whack too, sissy drum beats, etc. It failed to suck me in. And you know what it made be appreciate? Austin Power's opening scenes; they're amazing. (reported that he was OCD and probably brought people to tears making them do it perfect)
Also I was annoyed by the poor focus on Stone's face. I think they did it often because she's got freckles and stuff going on, but they didn't want to pack on makeup that would take away from her great expressions. I'm a fan, and I don't really see the problem with humanizing her (I'd still go on a date with her).
Overall it was surprisingly melancholy for a half musical. I personally would have liked to of seen some more out-there singing and dancing. Why not have Gosling jump up on a table and sing about how amazing Jazz makes him feel? (well, something) That's what the musical tool is for, showing emotions that can't possibly be conveyed in sensical manners. Also I think there was more room for Stone to use her wit, and goofy side. It's part of her, you can try to cover it up but... it's deeply part of her. (Easy A anyone? Crazy Stupid Love, the movie that made this one casting decisions?)
But I found the story rather pertinent to not only many, many people, but especially millennials that are told to find their dream, dream, dream dream, dream. But it appear to be a covert story for debt debt debt, especially with droves of idiots going to college. (I suppose Gosling is technically not a millennial, however, he obviously passes off as younger in every roll). Without a doubt I found myself with some strong emotional feelings. But that doesn't make up for desiring better editing, at least good sound, and some more energy into the musical side. My wishes, I do realize, are counter intuitive to millennials however. Older movies the people had more gusto to life, no question, even when they were down. People aren't that internally upbeat these days, the young generations, and they have many reasons but that doesn't mean I'm attached to seeing it on screen. Unlike how many younger people are anti-role-model, I don't care, give us something to look up to even when they have tragedy, despite life in the way.
I actually saw this with my mother, thinking she'd like it. She says it's good for Redbox. She LOVES old shows before her time, musical stuff, etc. She lives musical song in her head all the time she says. Now, she thought the ending was fine, and that when they looked at each other every thing was hunky-dory. We differ there. For me it raised the question is the ever pursuit of our dreams worth the expense? I'm not under the impression that they ever found a better love than each other. I'm not under the impression they wouldn't have been happier together like the montage-ish thing presented. To me it felt like it put values on family and love, and that running a little more with what life brings to you isn't so bad - as opposed to fighting, fighting everything to get your way before you know whether what you're asking for is what you should truly be wishing for... My mother believes that it's pretty much a common story to be forced between love and one's dream, and you'll never know if the other was the right choice. But her perspective is a bit different, she's never had the experience of a dream being crushed (it could be a reality for her in retirement, the one she has), nor has she ever been with "the one". And she couldn't care less about a significant other most of the time. Take it as you will, I suppose that's the best you can get from it without the creator telling you if they thought one choice was better. But, again, for me it hit home with wondering why (as a guy) we can be how we are & how much better we could have been, why we aren't always smart enough to jump on opportunity, and how much that can follow us around.
Despite how much it can get you thinking, how contemporary it is, it's still a movie and as such it's not that great. Plus the content isn't always fun for everyone. I use to think if a movie can drive emotions, it's as good as gold, but there's so many - especially indie films - that can make you feel down/depressed that it's getting old.
So I do recommend seeing it, but I actually agree, Redbox.