Magico Q7:" most impressive product in 23 years of TAS reviews" (R. Harley)

- what you describe as a louvers is a diffuser. It reflect more than 80% of sound, but diffused.
- the design has nothing to do about being ornate or not. It is optimized for efficiency. The wings diffusion pattern is superior to a classic quadratic diffuser.
- Goodwins room doesn't have any diffusion. Zero. It avoids parallel walls, that's it. It doesn't mean it cannot be a great sounding room. Unfortunately with room design, part is science, part is luck.
- I don't want to derail this thread.... but the the whole topic of Golden ratio for rooms dimension would justify a long explanation on why it is of little help on room design... as a start, the Golden ratios are calculated for a sound source positioned in a CORNER of a room. Do you put your speakers in the corner?
-Helmholtz resonators address room resonance on a narrow frequency band: see it like an absorber, which a narrow frequency response that you can tune. That means if you tune them on room nodes, you can selectively flatten the frequency response of the room. Only problem is you need quite a lot of them to work well. But they have the advantage to go much lower in frequency than soft absorbers like fiberglass.

You should read the book from Toole, and everything will be clearer to you. I did read a lot of books on acoustics, this is the best by far.

Nice to know of another member who read the "Sound Reproduction", although I doubt Toole would approve spending so much in the Q7 ! ;)

BTW, was your room designed by the same people who designed the The Sound Experience listening room? It looks it uses the same type of acoustic materials and style.
 

Attachments

  • aa1.jpg
    aa1.jpg
    60 KB · Views: 2,131
The fact that it looks very ornate doesn't make it better.

The room I posted of Goodwins (correctly identified by ack) is a live room with very good diffusion and very good dimensional proportions

Live the Goodwins rooms are not....
 
. . . . 27 Helmholtz resonators tuned on room nodes... Design by SMT in Sweden.
Here a simulation of the room:. . . .

I have a simple question: What are the dimensions of your Helmholtz Resonators
 
Magico Q7:" most impressive product in 23 years of TAS reviews" (R. Harley)

Gee, next month he will have to say some component is the most impressive product in 23 years and one month of TAS reviews.

You really think he went back 23 years and examined every product reviewed in order to make this grotesquerie?

TAS and Harley need hyperbole dampers, not resonators.
 
Magico Q7:" most impressive product in 23 years of TAS reviews" (R. Harley)

Gee, next month he will have to say some component is the most impressive product in 23 years and one month of TAS reviews.

You really think he went back 23 years and examined every product reviewed in order to make this grotesquerie?

TAS and Harley need hyperbole dampers, not resonators.

LOL, begs the question though...who is getting a pair ???
 
Nice to know of another member who read the "Sound Reproduction", although I doubt Toole would approve spending so much in the Q7 ! ;)

BTW, was your room designed by the same people who designed the The Sound Experience listening room? It looks it uses the same type of acoustic materials and style.

Yes, I believe this room is also designed by SMT. This is an older generation of their diffusers. Looks like a very small room, or it may be the angle of the picture.
In US, SMT has a partner, they just supply the diffusers, I am not sure they do the design themselves.
 
The sound expirience room, i smell good taste , my amps on steriods :D, on room acoustic level i have a lot to do still !!
Nice to know of another member who read the "Sound Reproduction", although I doubt Toole would approve spending so much in the Q7 ! ;)

BTW, was your room designed by the same people who designed the The Sound Experience listening room? It looks it uses the same type of acoustic materials and style.
 
Magico Q7:" most impressive product in 23 years of TAS reviews" (R. Harley)

Gee, next month he will have to say some component is the most impressive product in 23 years and one month of TAS reviews.

You really think he went back 23 years and examined every product reviewed in order to make this grotesquerie?

TAS and Harley need hyperbole dampers, not resonators.

It would be equally boring if he had said the Q7 are a "bit above average". :p One calls it an unnecessary hyperbole, the other a sign of utter enthusiasm. Poor guy, can't win ;)
 
Stereo have you heard the David Berning Quadrature Z. This tube amp will be able to keep up with the 7's. Very transparent, fast, and awesome tonality. Try High Fidelity Cables for cables.
 
BTW, I do not care if a loudspeaker is innovative or not, for me what counts is the final result.

I can't believe I missed this before now. Amen to that. The price to those who can truly appreciate that final result and afford it should never be in question.

Tom
 
Lol.....the XLF is reviewed by fremer in stereophile this month.....
By the way, are you demoing the Msb analog dac ? I'm most interested how it compares to the emm labs...

I'm on the list to get a demo unit in for auditioning. I'll report how it compares to the EMM labs.
 
I'm on the list to get a demo unit in for auditioning. I'll report how it compares to the EMM labs.

suggest you give also a try to the Metrum Hex. It is cheap (EUR2185), and very good. I find this new generation of non oversampling DACs quite interesting.
 
suggest you give also a try to the Metrum Hex. It is cheap (EUR2185), and very good. I find this new generation of non oversampling DACs quite interesting.

I was also intrigued by this DAC and looked into it. Opus111 on the forum told me it is most likely a 16 bit architecture, and upon asking the manufacturer I got no denial of that claim (so I assume it is true). This is a dealbraker for me.
 

About us

  • What’s Best Forum is THE forum for high end audio, product reviews, advice and sharing experiences on the best of everything else. This is THE place where audiophiles and audio companies discuss vintage, contemporary and new audio products, music servers, music streamers, computer audio, digital-to-analog converters, turntables, phono stages, cartridges, reel-to-reel tape machines, speakers, headphones and tube and solid-state amplification. Founded in 2010 What’s Best Forum invites intelligent and courteous people of all interests and backgrounds to describe and discuss the best of everything. From beginners to life-long hobbyists to industry professionals, we enjoy learning about new things and meeting new people, and participating in spirited debates.

Quick Navigation

User Menu