Tube or Solid State Pre Amp - which did you choose

Tube or Solid State Pre Amp


  • Total voters
    70
Personally, I have reached the audio summit, the peak of perfection, with SS Burmester 911 MK3 with tubed Concert Fidelity CF 080 LS/X. I have died and gone to heaven.
 
Wow...two to one in favor of tubes...(i am tube pre and SS amp)...i wonder how many of us use that combination?
 
Personally, I have reached the audio summit, the peak of perfection, with SS Burmester 911 MK3 with tubed Concert Fidelity CF 080 LS/X. I have died and gone to heaven.

Jim

I have had the 911 but mated with the Burmester 011 preamp .. Have you tried that?
 
Wow...two to one in favor of tubes...(i am tube pre and SS amp)...i wonder how many of us use that combination?

Although I favor all tubes , I am a tube preamp - SS amp user in the hot days of Summer. So I am now using my ARC's with a Classe power amplifier. But to compensate I am temporally hosting a pair of Wilson Audio MAXX3. They really sound quite different from the Soundlab's. :confused:
 
Although I favor all tubes , I am a tube preamp - SS amp user in the hot days of Summer. So I am now using my ARC's with a Classe power amplifier. But to compensate I am temporally hosting a pair of Wilson Audio MAXX3. They really sound quite different from the Soundlab's. :confused:

Hi Microstrip...how do they sound different? Appreciate your insights...i have never heard Soundlabs, but heard lots of great things about them. thanks.
 
Hi Microstrip...how do they sound different? Appreciate your insights...i have never heard Soundlabs, but heard lots of great things about them. thanks.

It is still too early to comment on it - may be in a few weeks I will be able to answer your question. I am now taking some acoustic panels that were used to control the back lateral reflections from my room.
 
fair enough...look forward to hearing more when they've all settled in and you've had time to really compare.
 
Solid state preamp and tube amp. They seem to balance each other out.
 
Solid state preamp and tube amp. They seem to balance each other out.

yes, agree...though i have more often heard of tube pre and SS amp...something about voicing of the pre and the deep bass strength, unflappable power of SS. just an observation...i respect there are many ways to audio nirvana.

in fact, so i can learn more...what SS pre and tube amp are you running?
 
yes, agree...though i have more often heard of tube pre and SS amp...something about voicing of the pre and the deep bass strength, unflappable power of SS. just an observation...i respect there are many ways to audio nirvana.

in fact, so i can learn more...what SS pre and tube amp are you running?

ARC LS3 and VT-100. One benefit of doing it the opposite way with a tube pre is less money in tubes. But I find my 1.6s have better midrange with tubes powering them although the Musical Fidelity A5 sounded great.
 
ARC LS3 and VT-100. One benefit of doing it the opposite way with a tube pre is less money in tubes. But I find my 1.6s have better midrange with tubes powering them although the Musical Fidelity A5 sounded great.

Thanks...i'll remember that...many ways to music nirvana...
 
I just picked up a McIntosh C2300---so put me in the tube preamp club.

If I used tube amps, I probably would actually get a ss preamp. While not as common, I feel it is the superior combination--because tube preamps really don't get that huge tube sound.
 
I owned the C2300 and it's as close as you can come to having a tube preamp with six 12AX7s that sounds like a SS preamp that I'm aware of. I would say that the ARC LS-17 isn't far behind it though. It just uses a lot fewer tubes in order to pull off its imatation of a SS preamp.
 
Like most others my first preamp was solid state. A Dynaco built from a kit, replaced by SAE (solid state) and then moved up to my "last" preamp a (solid state) late 1970's positively reviewed Technics dreadnaught with two phono inputs having adjustable capacitance and input sensitivity, dual treble and bass controls with frequency rollover conturing and other bells and whistles. It was replaced by a basic bare to the bones Conrad Johnson PV-3 tube preamp that I came across by chance at a yard sale. It cost 1/16 what I had payed for the Technics new.
The first LP played through the C-J was a rough UK Columbia pressing of Count Basie's "One More Time". Heaven! It seemed so real to me that I felt like I was in the recording studio.
There will be no turning back!
 
Like most others my first preamp was solid state. A Dynaco built from a kit, replaced by SAE (solid state) and then moved up to my "last" preamp a (solid state) late 1970's positively reviewed Technics dreadnaught with two phono inputs having adjustable capacitance and input sensitivity, dual treble and bass controls with frequency rollover conturing and other bells and whistles. It was replaced by a basic bare to the bones Conrad Johnson PV-3 tube preamp that I came across by chance at a yard sale. It cost 1/16 what I had payed for the Technics new.
The first LP played through the C-J was a rough UK Columbia pressing of Count Basie's "One More Time". Heaven! It seemed so real to me that I felt like I was in the recording studio.
There will be no turning back!

How many people have had that experience! I know I did!
 
How many people have had that experience! I know I did!

I had it and had it again when I flipped the other way and went back to SS. Once I first heard tubes, it made me allergic to anything that was SS. In my audio belief system, there was no place for SS. Now there is almost no place for tubes. The only tubes left in my system are my Ampex 350s which I find imperative for tape play back. For now, I'm done with tubes working me all of the time. It's time now to let SS work me over for awhile.
 

About us

  • What’s Best Forum is THE forum for high end audio, product reviews, advice and sharing experiences on the best of everything else. This is THE place where audiophiles and audio companies discuss vintage, contemporary and new audio products, music servers, music streamers, computer audio, digital-to-analog converters, turntables, phono stages, cartridges, reel-to-reel tape machines, speakers, headphones and tube and solid-state amplification. Founded in 2010 What’s Best Forum invites intelligent and courteous people of all interests and backgrounds to describe and discuss the best of everything. From beginners to life-long hobbyists to industry professionals, we enjoy learning about new things and meeting new people, and participating in spirited debates.

Quick Navigation

User Menu