No one can if he is on weekly basis. You really need to take a long time to optimize something. And that's why you learn more when you visit people who have optimized something.
True - I really agree with this. Well written!!
 
Your ears were trained on vocals.
This is exactly what I meant to say. You put it much more succinctly than I did. Thank you.

Regarding #2, I'm assuming you heard an amplified Stevie Nicks. The amplified version could not have been distortion free (no sound system is).
This is an excellent point.

Are you trying to achieve the version you heard live or an approximation of hearing her live without amplification?
I am not trying to achieve the version I heard live.

If I try to dissect it I am trying to achieve what I think Stevie would sound like if she were in my listening room. So this, I guess, has two components:

1) I want to feel like there is a living, breathing human in my listening room. (This is what I mean when I say "breath of life" from tube electronics.)

2) I want that human to sound like Stevie Nicks, unamplified.
 
  • Like
  • Haha
Reactions: Johan K and PYP
  • Haha
Reactions: Johan K
I think vocals are a lot harder than most people think. If the system gets it right, you should be having on occasion the experience of thinking someone got into your house and is singing along with your stereo. That can be a bit spooky.

Yes, I often call it bringing the dead back to life.

When I hear Dame Janet Baker, who is not dead, sing Elgar's Sea Songs, I am brought to tears, every time.

There is something powerful and ineffable about the human voice.
 
I think this is a very interesting conversation, Todd. Thank you.

1) This is going to be unsatisfying, and I cannot prove any of it. I have focused on vocals literally my entire life. It started when my father started bringing home LPs from Columbia and playing them on our home stereo in the living room when I was very young. I am recalling Olivia Newton-John and Karen Carpenter. I never heard any jazz or classical growing up. I literally grew up listening to vocals.

I have written previously that I think each of us is more or less sensitive to different kinds of sonic attributes. I have said candidly that I think I am relatively poor at perceiving concert hall ambience reproduced by stereo systems. I think I'm good at channel balance and tonal balance. I have never claimed to have great, let alone superior, hearing. I tell Don Saltzman all the time that he has much better hearing for this hobby than I do. That's why he's the reviewer.

But I think I'm good at perceiving the subtleties and nuances of vocals which may elude others.

I know that people feel "vocals are easy," and that vocals make every stereo sound good. I don't agree. I am extremely focused on and picky about vocal reproduction.

2) To answer your specific question I want Stevie Nicks, not a romanticized version of Stevie Nicks. I am not looking for a Vaseline beauty filter or a smoothing effect.

But digital and solid-state based systems which prioritize maximizing resolution and detail do not give me (my ears) Stevie Nicks. They give me an electronic-fied, sometimes slightly dry or otherwise unconvincing version of Stevie Nicks.
Perhaps you will appreciate Edith Piaf singing in the very end of this video:


Good "presence" that you can feel even through the video.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tima and morricab
LOL. Lampi was the dac I played in my system (which outdid the mediocre dacs you sold). Koetsu coralstone platinum signature, Allnic 7000, Dava Reference, vdh colibri, Ayon Orthos XS, Atmasphere m60 mk3, Berning Zh270, valves, etc were shipped around after I decided not to have a system, just to do so compares. I also paid a couple of dealers for their journeys to visit local audiophiles so that we could compare gear.

Why do you assume I am not familiar with these systems? Why do you always try to mislead by getting in random talking points
Am I reading correct that you are not going to have your own system even if you have a big house? Isn’t having a Hifi system to enjoy music?
 
Perhaps you will appreciate Edith Piaf singing in the very end of this video:


Good "presence" that you can feel even through the video.

Here is the track direct via YouTube:



In comparison the horn sounds quite colored.

I am not particularly impressed.
 
Here is the track direct via YouTube:



In comparison the horn sounds quite colored.

I am not particularly impressed.

You are probably correct, but we all focus on different aspects, and there is something in that sound that I find appealing.
 
Am I reading correct that you are not going to have your own system even if you have a big house? Isn’t having a Hifi system to enjoy music?
It's far easier to tell all and not own to deal with triels of making real decisions .
I think we need a 2 million dollar system to be allowed to post to people below lol.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Johan K
Perhaps you will appreciate Edith Piaf singing in the very end of this video:


Good "presence" that you can feel even through the video.
Thank you for trying. That one just happens not to work for me. To me that sounds very vintage-y (and not in a good way) -- like I'm listening to a Victrola from the 1920s.
 
Thank you for trying. That one just happens not to work for me. To me that sounds very vintage-y (and not in a good way) -- like I'm listening to a Victrola from the 1920s.

Yes, I thought it colored too, and indeed, the coloration is vintage-y. Actually, the male singer in the video prior to Edith Piaf singing is even worse. In comparison, Piaf sounds rather acceptable.
 
The OP started the thread about 2-1/2 years ago with pictures of crates being unloaded…
I am also pretty slow to a system together, but at some point it just needs to come together in whatever form.

….
I am not trying to achieve the version I heard live.

If I try to dissect it I am trying to achieve what I think Stevie would sound like if she were in my listening room. So this, I guess, has two components:

1) I want to feel like there is a living, breathing human in my listening room. (This is what I mean when I say "breath of life" from tube electronics.)

2) I want that human to sound like Stevie Nicks, unamplified.

I am getting a bit confused…
How can it sound like a living breathing person and NOT sound like the version one heard live (of a live/living person)?
 
How can it sound like a living breathing person and NOT sound like the version one heard live (of a live/living person)?
Live is electronically amplified.
 
Piaf voice was raspy and strong - an unique timbre. What we ear in her voice in a good system is not coloration - it is the rawness of her extremely dramatic and powerful style. Listen for enjoyment to Mylord or l'Homme a la Moto in your own system and forget about the poor videos ...

Most of her recordings are from the 40's to early 60's.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Johan K
Can you clarify what you mean by this? How are you learning? If someone has "optimized" something, are you listening with and without the "optimization"? You are listening to a complete system, so how else could you discern the "optimized" effect of something?
Hahaha, now we wait ….! :)
 
Live is electronically amplified.
OK Thanks - it makes a lot more sense now.

We saw a family friend singing last Sunday, and I was impressed with the quality of the audio.
I am not sure exactly what she was using, but it is helping a bit, but not dominating things.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lagonda

About us

  • What’s Best Forum is THE forum for high end audio, product reviews, advice and sharing experiences on the best of everything else. This is THE place where audiophiles and audio companies discuss vintage, contemporary and new audio products, music servers, music streamers, computer audio, digital-to-analog converters, turntables, phono stages, cartridges, reel-to-reel tape machines, speakers, headphones and tube and solid-state amplification. Founded in 2010 What’s Best Forum invites intelligent and courteous people of all interests and backgrounds to describe and discuss the best of everything. From beginners to life-long hobbyists to industry professionals, we enjoy learning about new things and meeting new people, and participating in spirited debates.

Quick Navigation

User Menu

Steve Williams
Site Founder | Site Owner | Administrator
Ron Resnick
Site Owner | Administrator
Julian (The Fixer)
Website Build | Marketing Managersing