Al M. is a digital only guy, and a digital proponent, but he too hears the virtues of vinyl and thinks it can do some things better than digital can. So, when you write that proponents of digital are in agreement, what do you mean? Could you please explain if they are digital only guys and what they are in agreement of?
Peter, our posts crossed. Yes, I do think that great vinyl like yours and Madfloyd's still does some things better than most digital, including mine (I would have to hear more from the dCS Vivaldi and other heavy weights in order to get a better idea of where they stand with repect to vinyl, and we will hear the NADAC shortly).
Yet I have repeatedly said that I am convinced that digital theory is correct, and that there is no loss of information by sampling -- and here I am in agreement with what is said in the video as well. Yet the perfection of digital theory is one thing, the imperfection of implementations thus far another. There are many practical pitfalls that prevent reaching the ideal of theory, as we both also have discussed over drinking coffee and on other occasions....
Again, I am in agreement with the theory as outlined in the video, which is well worth watching.