Tom,
I've learned to accept the fact that there are many things that occur in audio that we can hear but not necessarily explain.
Most recent example for me was my audition of the Pass X350.5. Great expectation bias on my part. I never thought I'd not like it but return it I did.
Funny you mention that.....expectation bias. My buddy had this Cary tube amp that I absolutely
drooled over because I heard it hooked up to two different system's at my buddy Jerry's house and at yet another system at an audio event. It had to have been one of the best sounding amps I had ever heard up 'till then. I told Jerry that I would own that very amp one day. He said, "over my dead body". I asked him where he would like to be buried.
All kidding aside. After begging him relentlessly and giving him grief for months on end, he
finally gave in and let me have the amp to see how it sounded in my system. Whooooo-Hoooo! So, I brought it up from Atlanta and hooked it up to the rig. I don't believe (personally) in expectation bias, only the end result as to what hits these ears but I will admit, I had extremely high hopes for this amplifier. Not only was it drop dead gorgeous, the sound I heard emanating from it was simply musical and the crème de la crème of sonic signatures. I just
knew it was gonna sound fantastic with my gear!
Wrong. Man, I must have messed with that amplifier and EVERYTHING in my system for two months. Changed out every upstream and downstream cable and PC, swapped out tubes in my pre and that amp like they were going out of style, messed with the bias running it normal, hot, low.....nothing seemed to work. That was a very good lesson in system synergy for me. After exhausting every option I had, I brought it back down to Jerry's pad and hooked it up to the very system I took it out of. Same tubes, same PC, same bias, same cables. The sound I loved from that amplifier came back like the past two months had never happened. *bangs head up against the wall*
I don't hear very often folks passing on Pass (no pun intended) but what happened to me with my "dream" Cary amp could have happened to you with the Pass. It simply did not work well with your system and said system lost it's synergy.
That is the sort of experience I would expect from long term audiophiles who are secure in trusting their ears and unlikely to fall prey to expectation bias.
These are the gentlemen I prefer to chat with in my own not so local audio group. Unfortunately, they are far and few between and spread from Canada to Florida to California and Washington State. I don't like lateral moves and I don't like fluff just because of a price tag. The only thing I care about is the end result as to what hits these ears.
Perhaps this could explain or be a part of the reason why some folks can hear (or detect) the subtleties of burn in or not. I don't mean to offend anybody with that statement, that is clearly not my intent but it is something that I personally believe to be true just based on my experience within this hobby. I had a few guys who were self claimed "audiophiles" that could not hear any difference between day one, two or day three with the Stratos. To me, that just simply blew my mind.......and I couldn't fathom how they couldn't. Different listening criteria levels, I guess. The well seasoned audiophile buddies from all over? Every one of them heard it and all observed the same thing I did.
Unfortunately, I know of many who fall prey to expectation bias.
Tom