2018 Oscar Nominations-And the Oscar Goes To..........
- Thread starter steve williams
- Start date
I started checking my watch about 30 minutes in and calculating how much longer I had to sit there.
We watched Lady Bird a few days ago. It was a good film but not Best Picture
Having said that if Francis McDormand is to have any competition I do feel that Saoirse Ronan was excellent in her role
Having said that if Francis McDormand is to have any competition I do feel that Saoirse Ronan was excellent in her role
I liked Shape of Water but in the end it just wasn’t best picture. For me Best Picture was I Tonya. Failing that I am going with Three Billboards as Best Picture
Steve, I would put Shape of Water behind I, Tonya and 3 Billboards as well. I enjoyed it but I didn’t think it had any depth other than it being an unusual love story. Shannon stole the show.
We watched Blade Runner 2049 tonight.
There was, however, a reason I’ve put off seeing it until now. And that reason was I could not for the life of me think of a reason for this film to exist.
The idea that perhaps the original film had a spiritual successor worthy of being made is not an invalid one. But an idea in itself is not a story, and a story in itself does not necessarily justify the existence of characters who fill in as cyphers for characters who were much more compelling the first time around.
Yes, it’s beautiful, but in a curiously contrived way that suffers terribly in comparison with the shadow left by Ridley Scott and Syd Mead’s visionary idealisation of dystopia. I am a huge fan of the work of Roger Deakins and his attempt to shoot as much in-camera as possible, and I guess if one can ever “deserve” an Oscar, then I see no reason to not award it to him this year.
But this film is all aesthetics. Despite an attempt by the screenwriters to reinvent the real/spectral free/slave dialectic for a woke audience, Blade Runner 2049 is all surface pleasures (and synthetically sterile ones at that), lacking both the previous film’s sense of morality and a symbolic web to strengthen our connection with the characters (the horse is doing waaay too much of the heavy lifting). I just didn’t care about the fate of anyone. When Harrison Ford’s character comes equal to the dog in terms of emotional investment, you have problems with a story that no amount of eye candy can fix, no matter how visually inventive (or distracting).
Perhaps the most disappointing thing from a director whose work I have liked, and actors whom I believe are capable of better work, is that there’s nothing in the premise to give legitimacy to the images. If ever there was a case of style over substance, this is it.
Oh yeah, and it is just too. Damn. Long.
Best,
853guy
There was, however, a reason I’ve put off seeing it until now. And that reason was I could not for the life of me think of a reason for this film to exist.
The idea that perhaps the original film had a spiritual successor worthy of being made is not an invalid one. But an idea in itself is not a story, and a story in itself does not necessarily justify the existence of characters who fill in as cyphers for characters who were much more compelling the first time around.
Yes, it’s beautiful, but in a curiously contrived way that suffers terribly in comparison with the shadow left by Ridley Scott and Syd Mead’s visionary idealisation of dystopia. I am a huge fan of the work of Roger Deakins and his attempt to shoot as much in-camera as possible, and I guess if one can ever “deserve” an Oscar, then I see no reason to not award it to him this year.
But this film is all aesthetics. Despite an attempt by the screenwriters to reinvent the real/spectral free/slave dialectic for a woke audience, Blade Runner 2049 is all surface pleasures (and synthetically sterile ones at that), lacking both the previous film’s sense of morality and a symbolic web to strengthen our connection with the characters (the horse is doing waaay too much of the heavy lifting). I just didn’t care about the fate of anyone. When Harrison Ford’s character comes equal to the dog in terms of emotional investment, you have problems with a story that no amount of eye candy can fix, no matter how visually inventive (or distracting).
Perhaps the most disappointing thing from a director whose work I have liked, and actors whom I believe are capable of better work, is that there’s nothing in the premise to give legitimacy to the images. If ever there was a case of style over substance, this is it.
Oh yeah, and it is just too. Damn. Long.
Best,
853guy
Of the nominated films, Lady Bird was my favorite.
I wouldn't be surprised to see a big upset on Best Picture. None of the films have taken a huge lead.
I wouldn't be surprised to see a big upset on Best Picture. None of the films have taken a huge lead.
Lady Bird was enjoyable but not my favorite. Having said that I believe if anyone can beat Francis McDormand it’s Saoirse Ronan
I really liked Lady Bird and Saorise is excellent but I wasn’t my favorite coming-of-age movie. I think I liked The Edge of Seventeen more. I thought Lady Bird had too many odd elements including a crazy mom, a first boyfriend who turned out to be gay, a childhood best friend who was dumped for cool kids and then a “first time” with the deep, cool HS kid. It just seemed a bit forced. But, I still liked it mainly due to Saorise’s performance.
Simple statistics ... can we see a miracle on Oscar's night?
• https://www.thestar.com/entertainme...-another-miracle-to-winning-best-picture.html
"Not since Grand Hotel in 1933 has a movie won Best Picture without having accompanying nominations for acting and writing."
___
I love Jennifer Lawrence; not only she is pretty but she's also outspoken and witty ...
• https://www.theringer.com/movies/20...er-lawrence-reviews-oscar-movies-best-picture
• https://www.thestar.com/entertainme...-another-miracle-to-winning-best-picture.html
"Not since Grand Hotel in 1933 has a movie won Best Picture without having accompanying nominations for acting and writing."
___
I love Jennifer Lawrence; not only she is pretty but she's also outspoken and witty ...
• https://www.theringer.com/movies/20...er-lawrence-reviews-oscar-movies-best-picture
The Florida Project
No one is talking about this film
[video]https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=WwQ-NH1rRT4[/video]
Over 96% positive on Rotten Tomatoes ??
Difficult to ever find in the theaters
We watched it On Demand and really enjoyed it.
What really made this film special was the role of Moonee played by the young Brooklyn Prince. We watched her throughout the movie and this kid is a natural. She never seemed to be acting as her facial expressions and gesticulations were so very real
The film runs 1 hour 55 minutes and is worth the watch if for no other reason than to watch the kids in this movie.
No one is talking about this film
[video]https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=WwQ-NH1rRT4[/video]
Over 96% positive on Rotten Tomatoes ??
Difficult to ever find in the theaters
We watched it On Demand and really enjoyed it.
What really made this film special was the role of Moonee played by the young Brooklyn Prince. We watched her throughout the movie and this kid is a natural. She never seemed to be acting as her facial expressions and gesticulations were so very real
The film runs 1 hour 55 minutes and is worth the watch if for no other reason than to watch the kids in this movie.
I have to respectfully disagree. I couldn't wait for the movie to be over. Ridiculous ending. The kid actors were all quite good but snooze alert.
Marty
You were snoozing no doubt as the kids were the movie and Brooklyn Prince was amazing in the role.
Movies they can do all sort of things to all of us. My best friend and I we agree 50% of the time on some movies and 95% on others. Occasionally one of us doesn't see what the other saw, less than 5%
The Florida Project is not your typical film, the main star is very young and the movie itself is simplicity in itself, just like watching kids, our grandchildren playing in our own backyards and frontyards.
There was a mention earlier about the movie 'Brooklyn', it's a love story, a beautiful love story and beautifully and romantically acted, I love that flick.
I understand 'The Florida Project' is very different, more raw, natural, not so much set with decors and mises-en-scènes, not projecting on a grander scale. That's the charm of this film, it's own aura. We are not used to watch simple life vignettes with young kids in such simple setting like a Florida motel.
I exited the film like I entered it, living it as an onscreen project of simple interaction between actors in their environment. I humbly accepted its premises and promises of real life.
The Florida Project is not your typical film, the main star is very young and the movie itself is simplicity in itself, just like watching kids, our grandchildren playing in our own backyards and frontyards.
There was a mention earlier about the movie 'Brooklyn', it's a love story, a beautiful love story and beautifully and romantically acted, I love that flick.
I understand 'The Florida Project' is very different, more raw, natural, not so much set with decors and mises-en-scènes, not projecting on a grander scale. That's the charm of this film, it's own aura. We are not used to watch simple life vignettes with young kids in such simple setting like a Florida motel.
I exited the film like I entered it, living it as an onscreen project of simple interaction between actors in their environment. I humbly accepted its premises and promises of real life.
I've read this fun interesting article earlier this morning, it's free for anyone having an interest in movies to read, but I thought it was worth it to share, so here it is:
• https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/l...name-is-wrong-post-got-spielberg-ized-1088406
___
Bonus: http://www.goldderby.com/article/2018/dunkirk-jordan-peele-secret-oscar-voter-ballot-news/
___
Only four days to go before Oscars night. I admit, I'm looking forward to it; not with high heels and tuxedo but for cinema curiosity, for the love of filmmakers and their cinematic arts. For the moving pictures and music accompaniment, for the accomplishments of movie entertainment. ...For the messages, for the culture, for what it can do in us emotionally and as a cultural and developed society, the magic power of film's art.
• https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/l...name-is-wrong-post-got-spielberg-ized-1088406
___
Bonus: http://www.goldderby.com/article/2018/dunkirk-jordan-peele-secret-oscar-voter-ballot-news/
___
Only four days to go before Oscars night. I admit, I'm looking forward to it; not with high heels and tuxedo but for cinema curiosity, for the love of filmmakers and their cinematic arts. For the moving pictures and music accompaniment, for the accomplishments of movie entertainment. ...For the messages, for the culture, for what it can do in us emotionally and as a cultural and developed society, the magic power of film's art.
Check this out, and be blown away:
• https://www.thestar.com/entertainme...out-could-win-best-picture-at-the-oscars.html
Of course it won't happen, or that would be the end for Hollywood.
But it was a cool flix nonetheless.
• https://www.thestar.com/entertainme...out-could-win-best-picture-at-the-oscars.html
Of course it won't happen, or that would be the end for Hollywood.
But it was a cool flix nonetheless.
Similar threads
