Saw it w/my girls on opening day -- they loved it, I thought it was weak. Part of it is you could feel the filmmakers struggling w/PG-13 on what is a brutal story. Still, none of the deaths had much impact or consequence -- maybe Rae, the girl who help Katniss' during the game, but that's it. Didn't like the shakicam either -- makes the action feel generic, and the constant cutting doesn't allow the performances to develop much rhythym -- Woody Harrelson forex. is never allowed really establish a perfomance groove. Bottom line is that there are several obviously vivid moments in the story, but none register with much impact. As an example -- think about the beginning of the fight when everyone goes up in the tubes to the outdoors -- should be high anticipation and drama here -- the parade too as another example -- but it all just goes by at the same tension level as everything else.
thought this was right on:
http://www.vulture.com/2012/03/movie-review-the-hunger-games.html
See Winter's Bone, an excellent low indie thriller, and you'll understand why Jennifer Lawrence was an obvious (and good) choice.