Active Crossovers

I went with the Marchand XM26 crossover because it is the simplest active crossover that I could find. It uses eight tubes total. I’m using new Genalex Gold Lion 12aX7 and 12aT7’s. This system is just as quiet with unbalanced interconnects as it is with balanced interconnects. No need for the added complexity of a balanced unit here.

If you only use one or two pole filters, the signal goes through three triode stages from input to each output. If you need three or four pole filters or require a notch filter, then the signal goes through four triode stages. According to Phil there are only two blocking capacitors in the signal path. I opted for the 0.5dB 24 step attenuators that he offers. They track within 0.01dB of each other so the imaging never shifts when fine tuning settings. It’s a great sounding minimalist design.

At my request, he customized it using HEXFRED diodes for the B+ bridge rectifier. Those provide the best midrange and most open high frequencies of any SS diodes that I have used. He also provided the frequency modules with Bessel filters and changed the circuit to optimize the output stage for a 12aT7 instead of 12aX7 so it can drive full output level into a 10k Ohm load. This was important because I use remote controlled attenuators with a 10k Ohm input impedance at the input of each power amp. This arrangement leaves the DAC’s full line level output connected directly to the crossover all the way through the 15’ interconnects to the mono-block amps located at the speakers. Having the volume control after the crossover and interconnects attenuates both the signal and any possible noise from everything upstream of the amps. It’s so quiet that even with my ears right up to the 107dB H.F. driver and 99dB L.F. driver, I can’t tell if the amps are turned on or off.

Before this a Pass Labs XVR-1 crossover was used in the system. Which is no slouch. In comparison the XM26 beats it in every regard. It sounds more transparent, more like a straight wire. With better low-level detail retrieval, dynamics, imaging and much more realistic bass and tone. Overall, everything sounds more real. I can definitely recommend it for a minimalist active crossover solution.
Very interesting info and confirms a lot of what I suspected regarding these tube crossovers. What frequency and slope are you using and what are the HF and LF drivers? Do you need and frequency response corrections? The drivers I use measure quite well and are possible to use with essentially no EQ.
 
1063Hz - 2 pole. Tannoy dual concentric15".
Phil is making me an additional set of 1063Hz 2 pole L.P. filter modules with a notch filter (-3dB @ 185Hz, Q of 1) to try.
Should have them within a week.
 
  • Like
Reactions: morricab
I went with the Marchand XM26 crossover because it is the simplest active crossover that I could find. It uses eight tubes total. I’m using new Genalex Gold Lion 12aX7 and 12aT7’s. This system is just as quiet with unbalanced interconnects as it is with balanced interconnects. No need for the added complexity of a balanced unit here.

If you only use one or two pole filters, the signal goes through three triode stages from input to each output. If you need three or four pole filters or require a notch filter, then the signal goes through four triode stages. According to Phil there are only two blocking capacitors in the signal path. I opted for the 0.5dB 24 step attenuators that he offers. They track within 0.01dB of each other so the imaging never shifts when fine tuning settings. It’s a great sounding minimalist design.

At my request, he customized it using HEXFRED diodes for the B+ bridge rectifier. Those provide the best midrange and most open high frequencies of any SS diodes that I have used. He also provided the frequency modules with Bessel filters and changed the circuit to optimize the output stage for a 12aT7 instead of 12aX7 so it can drive full output level into a 10k Ohm load. This was important because I use remote controlled attenuators with a 10k Ohm input impedance at the input of each power amp. This arrangement leaves the DAC’s full line level output connected directly to the crossover all the way through the 15’ interconnects to the mono-block amps located at the speakers. Having the volume control after the crossover and interconnects attenuates both the signal and any possible noise from everything upstream of the amps. It’s so quiet that even with my ears right up to the 107dB H.F. driver and 99dB L.F. driver, I can’t tell if the amps are turned on or off.

Before this a Pass Labs XVR-1 crossover was used in the system. Which is no slouch. In comparison the XM26 beats it in every regard. It sounds more transparent, more like a straight wire. With better low-level detail retrieval, dynamics, imaging and much more realistic bass and tone. Overall, everything sounds more real. I can definitely recommend it for a minimalist active crossover solution.
Wow! Ok I might seriously investigate doing the same!
 
  • Like
Reactions: aLLeARS
1063Hz - 2 pole. Tannoy dual concentric15".
Phil is making me an additional set of 1063Hz 2 pole L.P. filter modules with a notch filter (-3dB @ 185Hz, Q of 1) to try.
Should have them within a week.
I am running either 1Khz or 800Hz from a compression driver in wooden round Tractrix horn coupled to an 8 inch Supravox Alnico driver in a TQWT enclosure. With the Accuphase I found the 3rd order Butterworth filter worked better than the 2nd order filter. With the digital crossover I run at 1Khz with a 2nd order LR filter. I could apply EQ with the digital xover; however, I have found that once I have the levels well balanced I don't need any. The measurements show a quite flat response to about 8khz and then a gentle slope above that to 20Khz down about 3dB.
 
  • Like
Reactions: aLLeARS

About us

  • What’s Best Forum is THE forum for high end audio, product reviews, advice and sharing experiences on the best of everything else. This is THE place where audiophiles and audio companies discuss vintage, contemporary and new audio products, music servers, music streamers, computer audio, digital-to-analog converters, turntables, phono stages, cartridges, reel-to-reel tape machines, speakers, headphones and tube and solid-state amplification. Founded in 2010 What’s Best Forum invites intelligent and courteous people of all interests and backgrounds to describe and discuss the best of everything. From beginners to life-long hobbyists to industry professionals, we enjoy learning about new things and meeting new people, and participating in spirited debates.

Quick Navigation

User Menu