Alsyvox planars...prepare to sell your Magico's, YG's, Wilson's, Cessaro's. Maggie's, and all others!!

Ron Resnick

Site Co-Owner, Administrator
Jan 24, 2015
16,017
13,346
2,665
Beverly Hills, CA
Hi Ron, I auditioned the Rockport Altair back in 2007 for about 1 hour at Goodwin's high fi dealer in Waltham. The dealer has the most elaborately custom treated $200k audio room I've ever seen. I've always been a fan of Rockport Altair because it is highly balanced full range speakers with no major flaws. It can have a huge soundstage with realistic imaging when the recording has it. Tonally it is slightly on the warm side. The only criticism I have of Rockports in general is that they don't have the best transparency of good ribbon or electrostat speaker. But what dynamic speaker does? BTW, I auditioned two Magico speakers side by side to the Altair, the Magico Mini and some $150k aluminum chassis beer keg Magico monstrosity I don't recall the name of. IMO, they were both too bright and unlistenable. Unfortunatley, I have yet to hear a Magico I like. But the Rockports in general are some of the best dynamic speakers out there.

I would describe the Altair basically with exactly the same attributes as you describe it.
 

DaveyF

Well-Known Member
Jul 31, 2010
6,129
181
458
La Jolla, Calif USA
I have never represented specifically anyone’s opinion on the Lyras other than my own.
You are more than entitled to your opinion. That’s really not the point here. I am questioning whether or not you feel it possible that your opinion could be altered if you heard these cartridges in a different context, like the one that I have already presented ?
 

Ron Resnick

Site Co-Owner, Administrator
Jan 24, 2015
16,017
13,346
2,665
Beverly Hills, CA
It is the point because I was responding to your claim that I was speaking on behalf of others.

Given that I heard what I do not like in the context of over 10 different systems I am confident that my opinion on the Lyra Atlas will not be altered. To which you responded that each of those over 10 different systems must have been set-up in a faulty way or that each one of those over 10 different systems had misaligned Lyra cartridges.
 

DaveyF

Well-Known Member
Jul 31, 2010
6,129
181
458
La Jolla, Calif USA
It is the point because I was responding to your claim that I was speaking on behalf of others.

Given that I heard what I do not like in the context of over 10 different systems I am confident that my opinion on the Lyra Atlas will not be altered. To which you responded that each of those over 10 different systems must have been set-up in a faulty way or that each one of those over 10 different systems had misaligned Lyra cartridges.
No, you are misunderstanding me. What I am trying to point out to you is that your experience with the Lyra Atlas in the particular systems that you heard it, doesn’t automatically mean that you can ‘lump’ all of the Lyra cartridges into the same category. If you have not heard the Kleos, or the Delos,or the regular Etna, in a correctly set up fashion, then I believe you are faulty in your overall assumptions wherein you reference/assume the whole line exhibits the same Issues.

I would also state that the samplings you heard the Atlas in may not have been sufficient, thereby leading you to a conclusion about this cartridge that may not be accurate, if it was in a different context. Certainly, you may have heard this particular cartridge (the Atlas) in enough instances to come to an accurate conclusion....but my point is...are you open to the suggestion that this might not be case?
 

Al M.

VIP/Donor
Sep 10, 2013
8,681
4,470
963
Greater Boston
Al, I heard the Lyra Delos three weeks ago at Audio Element.

My ears hear the Lyras as having a similar “house” sound, except for the Etna SL, which I think I hear as fantastic without the leanness/analytical attributes.

O.k., thanks, Ron.
 

morricab

Well-Known Member
Apr 25, 2014
9,391
4,986
978
Switzerland
So after seven pages and admissions of fallibility, has anyone decided to sell their speakers and try these new planars? I'd like to hear them but it seems many here like what they have and are not looking for big changes.
Here we go again - thermal distortion is not an issue since long ... Engineers monitor the real current in the coil easily ... It is not rocket science, just basic Kirchhoff's and Ohm's law at audio frequencies ...

BTW, using a simple talk, sometimes the keyword to separate these different categories is time - delayed errors are different from excitation errors.

Anyway, I fail to understand how horn lovers in WBF seem to completely ignore Paul Wilbur Klipsch papers on the science and sonic advantages of horns and go on just with coffee talk such as easiness ... Perhaps because it needs a little of mathematics to be debated ...
Too expensive for me or I would seriously consider it...right after I got a pair of Aries Cerat Symphonias !
 
  • Like
Reactions: CGabriel

bazelio

Well-Known Member
Sep 26, 2016
2,493
1,745
345
California
So after seven pages and admissions of fallibility, has anyone decided to sell their speakers and try these new planars?

Hopefully not without hearing them first. To round out the thread with (alternate) opinions from associates of mine who attended RMAF:
  • Terribly off timbre; for example: stringed instruments sounded plasticky.
  • Utterly lifeless.
  • Tonally very dark.
  • Non-existent bass impact. (Apparently the dealer was explaining "real bass" and then when the bass hit, the room chuckled. The descriptor "mouse fart" was used.)
I'd say based on our conversations about Asylovox speakers, I have no interest in ever hearing them myself. I know their ears too well to bother. They sure are lookers though!

PS - Context matters, and this was reported in the context of the RMAF system configuration.
 
Last edited:

DaveyF

Well-Known Member
Jul 31, 2010
6,129
181
458
La Jolla, Calif USA
Hopefully not without hearing them first. To round out the thread with (alternate) opinions from associates of mine who attended RMAF:
  • Terribly off timbre; for example: stringed instruments sounded plasticky.
  • Utterly lifeless.
  • Tonally very dark.
  • Non-existent bass impact. (Apparently the dealer was explaining "real bass" and then when the bass hit, the room chuckled. The descriptor "mouse fart" was used.)
I'd say based on our conversations about Asylovox speakers, I have no interest in ever hearing them myself. I know their ears too well to bother. They sure are lookers though!

PS - Context matters, and this was reported in the context of the RMAF system configuration.


What you stated is exactly why we have such diversity of opinions in this hobby. The a'phile who gave you these opinions ( and that's what they are, nothing more or less) believed all that he told you. The a'phile friend of mine, had the exact opposite opinion. Who's right and who's wrong? i suspect that they are both right...and both wrong!
As we all know, speakers can sound different based on ancillary gear, set up and a host of other variables, even on a day to day basis. Your friend probably heard them when they were perhaps newly set up and not totally dialed in...or perhaps not; my friend heard them when they were totally dialed in and at their best...or perhaps he just didn't hear what your friend heard...and vice versa!
ONLY way to know for sure, is to listen for oneself in one's own system. Like all gear under consideration, IME.
 

bazelio

Well-Known Member
Sep 26, 2016
2,493
1,745
345
California
It's going to come down to a matter of preference, and I know these folks' preferences very well. We've heard a LOT of the same gear and discussed it many, many times. So now when they describe something in detail to me, I get a very good feel. In this case, there were 4 associates of mine in the same suite at the same time. The descriptions I've relayed were unanimous among them. My point really only being this (and mainly in response to PeterA): Don't sell your stuff for these planars without hearing them first! Because at least in the opinion of some, the Asylovox suite was not only unimpressive but it might have been among the worst at the show.
 

bonzo75

Member Sponsor
Feb 26, 2014
22,441
13,469
2,710
London
Hopefully not without hearing them first. To round out the thread with (alternate) opinions from associates of mine who attended RMAF:
  • Terribly off timbre; for example: stringed instruments sounded plasticky.
  • Utterly lifeless.
  • Tonally very dark.
  • Non-existent bass impact. (Apparently the dealer was explaining "real bass" and then when the bass hit, the room chuckled. The descriptor "mouse fart" was used.)
I'd say based on our conversations about Asylovox speakers, I have no interest in ever hearing them myself. I know their ears too well to bother. They sure are lookers though!

PS - Context matters, and this was reported in the context of the RMAF system configuration.

Neither impression can be made in show context. This is an amazing thread, about the "ears we trust who listen and and judge in a show context"
 

bazelio

Well-Known Member
Sep 26, 2016
2,493
1,745
345
California
Neither impression can be made in show context. This is an amazing thread, about the "ears we trust who listen and and judge in a show context"

What's amazing is the thread subject advocates selling gear to buy planars based on a report under show conditions. To counter that, I've simply posted what was heard in the same suite, at the same show, with the same gear. Show conditions are what they are, and ultimately leave a lot to be desired. This is precisely why we should *not* be saying sell X and buy planars based on show hearsay. That's my point. What's yours?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ron Resnick and MPS

bonzo75

Member Sponsor
Feb 26, 2014
22,441
13,469
2,710
London
What's amazing is the thread subject advocates selling gear to buy planars based on a report under show conditions. To counter that, I've simply posted what was heard in the same suite, at the same show, with the same gear. Show conditions are what they are, and ultimately leave a lot to be desired. This is precisely why we should *not* be saying sell X and buy planars based on show hearsay. That's my point. What's yours?

The title was over blown. Already been said. We can't give negative reviews either based on show hearsay. Dr K is buying them? Let's wait to hear from him.
 

bazelio

Well-Known Member
Sep 26, 2016
2,493
1,745
345
California
The title was over blown. Already been said. We can't give negative reviews either based on show hearsay. Dr K is buying them? Let's wait to hear from him.

We can review show suites (or in this case relay reviews of them). But obviously, we might not reach the same conclusion under more favorable or controlled conditions. Been there, done that, etc. Still, I'm unlikely to believe that under different conditions these speakers will somehow turn for the better to the required degree. But that's just me.
 

microstrip

VIP/Donor
May 30, 2010
20,806
4,698
2,790
Portugal
It's going to come down to a matter of preference, and I know these folks' preferences very well. We've heard a LOT of the same gear and discussed it many, many times. So now when they describe something in detail to me, I get a very good feel. In this case, there were 4 associates of mine in the same suite at the same time. The descriptions I've relayed were unanimous among them. My point really only being this (and mainly in response to PeterA): Don't sell your stuff for these planars without hearing them first! Because at least in the opinion of some, the Asylovox suite was not only unimpressive but it might have been among the worst at the show.

Four people in the suite at the same time is just one data point. And IMHO four people complete unanimity in this hobby is too polarized to be taken without many grains of salt, unless we have more specific details about the performance, considering some other people report great performance.

Perhaps these are great speakers - who knows? - but for me they are being shown under the aura of being expensive and mysterious unobtainium ...

And yes, I am allergic to unobtainium high-end products ...
 

bazelio

Well-Known Member
Sep 26, 2016
2,493
1,745
345
California
It's four data points. These folks have all sorts of different personal preferences among them, from vinyl only to digital only, tubes only, solid state only, and mixes thereof. The rarity of such consensus, yes, extreme. And telling.

Anyhow, 'nuff said.
 

dr k

VIP/Donor
Aug 4, 2016
218
102
260
California
Hopefully not without hearing them first. To round out the thread with (alternate) opinions from associates of mine who attended RMAF:
  • Terribly off timbre; for example: stringed instruments sounded plasticky.
  • Utterly lifeless.
  • Tonally very dark.
  • Non-existent bass impact. (Apparently the dealer was explaining "real bass" and then when the bass hit, the room chuckled. The descriptor "mouse fart" was used.)
I'd say based on our conversations about Asylovox speakers, I have no interest in ever hearing them myself. I know their ears too well to bother. They sure are lookers though!

PS - Context matters, and this was reported in the context of the RMAF system configuration.


Interesting...All my sources from RMAF were saying completely opposite of what your associates claimed. Several reviewers including Johnathen Valin of TAS and Peter Breuninger of AV Showrooms, Terry Eningi were stunned by the lifelike, extended, dynamic Botticelli sound. JV said the Botticelli was only speaker he wanted to review. Yes, context matters. The RMAF system was the same for your associates and my sources and reviewers alike. Just goes to show you how differently people hear and have different preferences.

Also, coming to conclusion based on how badly a speaker sounds at a show is a poor way of judging a speaker. I can name many great speakers that sounded bad at shows.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: christoph

Al M.

VIP/Donor
Sep 10, 2013
8,681
4,470
963
Greater Boston
Still, I'm unlikely to believe that under different conditions these speakers will somehow turn for the better to the required degree. But that's just me.

Don't underestimate just how abominably bad great gear can sound at shows. As I've said many times before:
  • if something sounds great at a show, then great, an important data point
  • if something sounds bad at a show, it can have many, many reasons *), and it's a meaningless data point
_______________________
*) for example, how about different opinions being based on different power conditions in those lousy hotel rooms during different times of the day? -- not as improbable as some might think, and might help explain the vastly divergent opinions
 

microstrip

VIP/Donor
May 30, 2010
20,806
4,698
2,790
Portugal
It's four data points. These folks have all sorts of different personal preferences among them, from vinyl only to digital only, tubes only, solid state only, and mixes thereof. The rarity of such consensus, yes, extreme. And telling.

Anyhow, 'nuff said.

In sound reproduction, the conditions you describe do not allow me (and many others) to consider them as independent data points. And theoretically, for me, in this case it is just one half data point - indirect testimony, as they say. :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: DaveyF and bonzo75

bonzo75

Member Sponsor
Feb 26, 2014
22,441
13,469
2,710
London
Yes. This is noise not data points.
 

About us

  • What’s Best Forum is THE forum for high end audio, product reviews, advice and sharing experiences on the best of everything else. This is THE place where audiophiles and audio companies discuss vintage, contemporary and new audio products, music servers, music streamers, computer audio, digital-to-analog converters, turntables, phono stages, cartridges, reel-to-reel tape machines, speakers, headphones and tube and solid-state amplification. Founded in 2010 What’s Best Forum invites intelligent and courteous people of all interests and backgrounds to describe and discuss the best of everything. From beginners to life-long hobbyists to industry professionals, we enjoy learning about new things and meeting new people, and participating in spirited debates.

Quick Navigation

User Menu

Steve Williams
Site Founder | Site Owner | Administrator
Ron Resnick
Site Co-Owner | Administrator
Julian (The Fixer)
Website Build | Marketing Managersing