Moving away from box speakers: Diesis Audio vs Avantgarde Acoustic?

Front to back is easy: I’ll just measure the wall which has window. The front wall has a built in cupboard which is diagonal to the wall. So where to measure?

Based on your current picture, window is side wall. Front wall is the wall between the speakers facing listener in centre seat
 
Below is another picture of my room, that should give you a better idea of its challenges. Based on this picture what is your view of the best option out of the 3 room wise?
1. Avantgarde UNO SD
2. Diesis Caput Mundi
3. Clarisys Minuet

Thanks in advance,
Aziz
View attachment 139753

Uno SD G3 would work here but so would the Odeon Helix and Horning Aristotle Ellipse. With those speakers you can use moderate powered tube amps. I would not use Itron for Uno as it sounds really a lot better with a good SET for the mid and high horns.

Diesis is great sounding but I think you need more space in the room than you have based on the photos. The smaller Aura would fit better but again bass will be an issue being open baffle without sufficient space behind them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: abeidrov
Based on your current picture, window is side wall. Front wall is the wall between the speakers facing listener in centre seat
And? When say measure front to back you mean the side wall?
 
And? When say measure front to back you mean the side wall?
No wall between the speakers to the wall behind the listener. I am just trying to gauge the distance to see what speakers can fit pulled in from the wall
 
No wall between the speakers to the wall behind the listener. I am just trying to gauge the distance to see what speakers can fit pulled in from the wall
That is the length of the side wall:) The wall that has window.
 
I think it’s about 4 meters, but I’ll do the exact measurement in the evening, when I am at home.
 
Check out the Destination Audio Nika Speakers! They come highly recommended and delivered outstanding sound quality at the Munich event.
 
Heretical on this forum, but the Kii3’s have terrific performance in a small form factor, and, were designed from the ground up to mitigate room and placement issues.

 
Based on the picture of your room, I don't see any issues getting the Uno SD to work perfectly. As was mentioned earlier, the directivity of horns makes the room much less of a problem. One of the huge advantages the Uno SD offers over the other choices is that the bass is active. This means that you can make it work in tight spaces. You have volume control that allows a range of -12.0 to +12.0 dB in 0.5 dB increments. You also have DSP available to use. As someone mentioned, AG developed a new interface for the DSP that makes it very simple to use. Of cousre the full blown DSP interface is in the background and your dealer should be able to help you with that if needed. If not then I can help you via e-mail or phone.

There are really two decisions: what color do you want and how do you want to power them. You can go fully active with the iTron amp which is a 2 channel, 3 Watt per channel, fully class A, no negative feedback, current amplifier. In this instance you simply run a pair of XLR over from your preamp and each speaker has two power cords. OR you can choose the tube amp that produces sound that you like.

Call you Avantgarde dealer and ask for a demo. I don't know which country you are in but Europe has many dealers.
 
  • Like
Reactions: abeidrov
Below is another picture of my room, that should give you a better idea of its challenges. Based on this picture what is your view of the best option out of the 3 room wise?
1. Avantgarde UNO SD
2. Diesis Caput Mundi
3. Clarisys Minuet

Thanks in advance,
Aziz
View attachment 139753
The back wall behind the listening position can cause issues with low frequencies, regardless of the loudspeakers used.
 
Heretical on this forum, but the Kii3’s have terrific performance in a small form factor, and, were designed from the ground up to mitigate room and placement issues.

Yes, although, like the Dutch & Dutch speakers, the Kii relies entirely on its DSP abilities.

Thus (if you look at it logically) the nice accurate Signal, that your costly amp was bought to deliver, is Processed (the S and P in DSP) and messed with according to what the measuring microphone says. The accuracy of the amplifier or in fact the speakers (if they were accurate without DSP) is irrelevant and ignored by DSP.

I'm far from convinced that DSP is a better route than getting an accurate system and doing a little physical work to get the room's perceived difficulties dealt with to an acceptable degree.
 
From the picture the OP is sitting very close to the back wall. Maybe 30-50cm. There are two issues. One is the null caused by SBIR. However, he is sitting so close that this is not going to be in the bass region (maybe 300Hz or so). This could be fixed by adding a panel to the wall behind the head. The other, and likely bigger issue, is that sitting so close to the wall will produce big bass peaks due to the room modes. However, this is where the Duo SD sets itself apart from the others. The OP could use the built in DSP function to pull the peaks down to make a flat bass response.

Don't get me wrong. I am not advocating tons and tons of DSP. I view it as a tool just like anything else. Typically, just one or two filters are normally sufficient to make a very good listening experience.
 
  • Like
Reactions: abeidrov
IME horns, while more directional than cones aren't any more directional than panels. In fact, horn drivers need more distance to integrate well at the listening spot, and your room is of modest proportions (like most of us). As such, (not to mention I haven't heard a single pair of horns that integrated well and never sound natural to me) I'd recommend the Clarisys Minuet. I know folks who've heard them and rave about the natural tonality and uncommonly incredible dynamics. Good luck in your pursuit and enjoy!
 
  • Like
Reactions: abeidrov and Golum
I think the Diesis is a good choice, the Caput Mundi has 12” “woofers” and while you won’t get the same visceral punch as the Wilsons, and maybe not go quite as deep, absent the typical bump @ around 70 hz of the Wilson’s, you’ll get more tuneful, natural sounding bass. Giuseppe is a real artist and I think his speakers get to the beauty in the music much better than many. I think the smaller models you may not get bass near what you’re used to with your Wilsons.

And yes, Diesis speakers setup easier than most. They are not recommended to be toed-in more than 20 degrees, so almost straight forward.
 
  • Like
Reactions: abeidrov
No wall between the speakers to the wall behind the listener. I am just trying to gauge the distance to see what speakers can fit pulled in from the wall
The back wall is uneven and is further away behind the right speaker compared to behind the left speaker, please see the attached picture. Front to back where the left speaker is 4.8 meters, right speaker - 5.3 meters.IMG_3447.jpeg
 
I think the Diesis is a good choice, the Caput Mundi has 12” “woofers” and while you won’t get the same visceral punch as the Wilsons, and maybe not go quite as deep, absent the typical bump @ around 70 hz of the Wilson’s, you’ll get more tuneful, natural sounding bass. Giuseppe is a real artist and I think his speakers get to the beauty in the music much better than many. I think the smaller models you may not get bass near what you’re used to with your Wilsons.

And yes, Diesis speakers setup easier than most. They are not recommended to be toed-in more than 20 degrees, so almost straight forward.
Is there a minimum recommended distance from the listening position and to the front wall for the Caput Mundi?
 

About us

  • What’s Best Forum is THE forum for high end audio, product reviews, advice and sharing experiences on the best of everything else. This is THE place where audiophiles and audio companies discuss vintage, contemporary and new audio products, music servers, music streamers, computer audio, digital-to-analog converters, turntables, phono stages, cartridges, reel-to-reel tape machines, speakers, headphones and tube and solid-state amplification. Founded in 2010 What’s Best Forum invites intelligent and courteous people of all interests and backgrounds to describe and discuss the best of everything. From beginners to life-long hobbyists to industry professionals, we enjoy learning about new things and meeting new people, and participating in spirited debates.

Quick Navigation

User Menu