1. I do not want any part of my plinth to act as a "tone board"!
2. The use of Panzerholz to "decouple" the motor vibrations from the tonearm/cartridge is exactly why I am choosing Panzerholz as my plinth material.
3. The plinth will be further decoupled from the rack (and foot traffic) by Townshend seismic pods underneath.
4. My turntable will have a new solid machined from aluminium billet chassis (to which the turntable motor is mounted as well) which (as you spell out) stacks different materials, so as you say, acts as further physical impedance, so in effect, I will have Panzerholz sandwiched between aluminium and Townshend pods in a way that is similar to the Clearaudio Statement V2 (at a fraction of the cost)?
5. My turntable will also have a heavy duty bearing/spindle assembly holding a 20Kg brass (another material change) platter, adding solidity and weight like (but to a lesser extent) the Rossner and Sohn Mott (325kg) and J.C. Verdier La Plantine Magnum (400kg), and further decoupling the engine rumble from the record groove.
Taiko, and Ovenmitt, I have read and re-read your explanations and hope that my comments above prove that I understand what you are saying and have answered concerns, however I still have no idea how some vibrations from the turntable motor being allowed to get through to the tonearm and cartridge improve sound (less deadened). I am beginning to wonder if you are used to a little even-order harmonic distortion coming through which, like that from valves, sounds warmer, and when missing seems "over deadened"?
In my experience, you definitely want to decouple the motor from everything else as much as possible, whether you are using idler or belt. DDs have their own rather intriguing issues that brings into play the idea of coupling the tonearm to the bearing or not. One important thing to consider, as Taiko explained, is that one must pay attention to how the material behaves across the entire spectrum. That it damps well above its resonant frequency is good, but if the application amplifies the self resonance at 2500 Hz, then the higher frequencies may seem over-damped
in comparison. There are many ways to move the resonant frequency around, including mass (as one increases mass its resonant frequency decreases), and by selective cutting/modification of the surface (again, see Taiko). As in much of life, it is about finding the appropriate balance.
Panzerholz is a superb material, but it certainly does not come down to how well it damps solely. That's just a part of the equation, as Taiko has discovered and implemented beautifully in his products. In particular, there are charlatans (actually, only one, really) on many fora who pretends to have tested all materials for their damping characteristics and concluded that 20mm of Panzerholz is the perfect plinth. No more, no less. Apart from the testing methodology being beyond laughable, the rest of his "science" fails basic physics 101. But for some reason, people listen. Dunning-Kruger has that effect on some people...He once got furious for the suggestion that the new SME plinths had a combination of materials, including phenolic resin. Phenolic resin is another really amazing material, and just because it is also used to make high-impact resistant toilet partitions doesn't mean it is somehow a degraded material....Panzerholz, by the by, is made of highly compressed wood and.....phenolic resin. It is fancy plywood.
The long and the short of this is that, as one can see by the broad range of solutions that many amazing turntable manufacturers have developed with spectacular results, there is no magic solution. There is thinking through the problem, then experimenting. In the end, it has to sound good to you.
For those curious, Delignit (the German manufacturer of Panzerholz) also makes a few other rather interesting materials, including Festholz, which claims sound deadening characteristics (not claimed by Delignit for Panzerholz!), and Carbonwood, which is compressed Beechwood and carbon fiber reinforcing. It's hard to come by in the States, but I would be interested to try it.