In the US Supreme Court case Jacobellis v Ohio from 1964, Justice Potter Stewart, in attempting to describe the threshold test for obscenity (pornography), stated that he could "never succeed in intelligibly doing so". He continued nevertheless: "But I know it when I see it".
Likewise, I find it difficult to describe in words how a Pass power amplifier is "lifeless". But I know it when I hear it!
Still, perhaps I could describe how how two different power amplifiers drive my current TAD CR1 TX speakers (very difficult to drive). The top of the line Accuphase A-250 Class A monoblocks (100 Class A watts per channel) at my dealer produce a nice textured sound, but the sound is not very dynamic, there is no "juice", no "jump". The power amplifiers I own, the top of the line TAD M700 Class AB monoblocks (350 Class AB watts per channel) have that "juice" and "jump". On listening to the CR1s with the TAD amplifiers (this may be an unfair comparison, since, after all, they were designed to drive the CR1s as well as possible by the very same TAD), you can hear immediately that one is in a completely different (and better) world, the TAD amplifiers are the natural mate for the TAD speakers.
So, although I haven't heard the Pass amplifiers with my TAD speakers, I have heard them in many other contexts, and I (your mileage may vary, as they say) have never been impressed with their obvious lack of "juice" and "jump" with many different speakers. I remember, for example, that the Pass amplifiers were completely outclassed by the Goldmund amplifiers driving the Sonus Faber Stradivari Homage speakers (which I owned for thirteen years!).
However, using the same make amplifier with the same make speakers is not always the best solution. For example, the Thrax Spartacus 300B mono power amplifiers do not drive the Thrax Lyra speakers very well, too little "juice" and "jump".
Trial and error to find the best match between amplifier and speakers is the only method which works.
By the way, in my opinion (again), matching the preamplifier and the power amplifier (usually by buying the same brand) is also not the best way to go about getting a synergistic system.
The matchings which are important are the internal matchings for three subsystems, the upstream, midstream, and downstream.
First, one should try to match the upstream (sources). I have only one, the Taiko SGM Extreme server/streamer, so that's easy.
Second, one should match the midstream. So I have the Nagra HD DAC X and the Nagra HD Preamplifier HV, both with tubes and separate super capacitor power supplies, which really helps with the "juice" and "jump".
Third, one should match the downstream. So I've matched my TAD CR1 TX speakers with the TAD M700 mono power amplifiers: a match made in heaven! Some friends tell me that I should match my Nagra preamp with the Nagra HD monos, but, in my opinion, that's completely missing the point. The most important match in any sound system, and the most difficult one to get right, is the match between power amplifier and speakers. Any change to my current TAD monos would destroy the wonderful synergy I've discovered between my amplifiers and speakers! So no go.
Ron
Singapore