Hopkins' System

Sonny Rollins, on his "Saxophone Colossus" 1956 album:


Sonny Rollins – tenor saxophone
Tommy Flanagan – piano
Doug Watkins – bass
Max Roach – drums

Jan Evensmo's comments on the track: “…one of Sonny Rollins' very best recorded ballads ever, played so strongly and confidently, what can be better tenorsax playing than this!!??" (https://www.jazzarcheology.com/sonny-rollins/)

There are obviously other great tenor saxophonists - we tend to forget the others when listening to one. The best jazz musicians each have such unique ways of playing that it does not really make sense to rank them, though you can certainly have your personal favorites. I'm sure Evensmo would agree, and he was just expressing his enthusiasm.

But has Sonny Rollins himself ever played better than on this date? Let me know...

Digital version of the album. Recording volume is again probably a little high.

In-room impressions: lively (as in the music comes to life). Not aggressive and fatiguing (my cat sleeps throughout). No major issues that distract me from being absorbed by the music. I'm very happy with this system. I must not be a true audiophile.

I've never heard Rollins live, and even if I had, he plays differently today than he did back then. But the sound is convincing to my ears. I feel like I'm hearing someone blowing in a saxophone, and not some artificial construct. That's what matters to me. The rest (super clean bass,shimmering highs, etc...) is not necessary for my listening enjoyment.
 
Last edited:
I was not happy with the sound of that previous recording from my phone. It sounded thin. I don't know what's going on with my phone.

I took another one with my tablet (Samsung). The sound is blurred at times in the video, as I probably put my hands in front of the microphone. Also during the piano solo I seem to be breathing heavily! Nevertheless, the sound is a little closer to what I hear in my room.

There are still significant differences here between the recording and how it sounds in my room...


My Tascam recorder has broken down, so I don't really have any other options at the moment, but I would like to make a good recording, and see how close one can come to the sound of the speakers in the room. I may rent a microphone and recorder for a day.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: 2ndLiner

A 400€ speaker with 4000€ of electronics upsets conventional audiophile wisdom?

The vocals sound very nice to my ears ("natural"?). I really enjoy how the vocals and instruments are "layered" (what Salvatore refers to as "organized").

This morning I was listening to Frank Sinatra, and his voice sounds marvellous on the system, but a more modern track also reveals that the bass could certainly be deeper and fuller. I'm happy with the overall sound, and would not want to sacrifice the "positives" for some deeper notes that my room and pockets may not be able to handle anyway!
 
Last edited:

A 400€ speaker with 4000€ of electronics upsets conventional audiophile wisdom?

The vocals sound very nice to my ears ("natural"?). I really enjoy how the vocals and instruments are "layered" (what Salvatore refers to as "organized").

This morning I was listening to Frank Sinatra, and his voice sounds marvellous on the system, but a more modern track also reveals that the bass could certainly be deeper and fuller. I'm happy with the overall sound, and would not want to sacrifice the "positives" for some deeper notes that my room and pockets may not be able to handle anyway!
The tracks you post sound really captivating, H! Have you ever considered a bass array system?
 
Another track that stopped me in my tracks :)


It didn't stop my cat in his tracks - unfortunately he heard walking around with his collar bell...
I wish I had a better recording system.

When I listen to this track in my room, I do get a sense of a "black background", low noise floor, whatever you want to call it. A phone's microphone, however, can't really capture this, precisely because it has a higher noise floor ...
 
Last edited:
These days I have been listening to Benny Carter a lot. His recording career spans many decades, so there is a lot to choose from.

Here is an excerpt from a 1968 live recording in Switzerland:


The "original" track (in stereo):


This is the kind of track I can set on repeat and listen to over and over again for a few hours and never get tired of.

The album was only issued on CD. It sounds great.

The first seven tracks are with Carter.
 
Last edited:
For all the fans of Ella Fitzgerald out there, here is a good album with Benny Carter as musical director (he also plays alto saxophone):



It is a series of medleys.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2ndLiner
Here's a mellow track by Yusef Lateef:


The album, never issued on CD, is discussed in this blog:


The author includes two tracks so you can get a better idea of the recording quality than through a system video.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Argonaut
Interestingly, Loren Schoenberg comments on the sound in the liner notes to that Strayhorn/Hodges album - I assume this is after listening to the stereo version:

"A word about the sound - although Rudy Van Gelder's achievements as a recording engineer are generally beyond reproach, I feel that Strayhorn's orchestrations are not well served by this sort of balance and separation of sections. This may have been done at the request of the record label, but nonetheless, the various sections of the band do their best to maintain the mystery that was so essential to the Ellingtonian effect, as it was known."
 
If memory Serves Count Basie refused to work with Van Gilder , as he felt his styled pumped up the music too much and killed the essence of what he ( Basie ) was looking for in his recordings ....
 
  • Like
Reactions: hopkins
As a kid, over 50 years ago, I was really surprised to hear my own voice for the first time, at the science museum in Philadelphia. From what I vaguely remember, you could speak through a phone and hear you voice on a headphone.

Here's a video of my voice recorded on my phone and then played back through my speakers (far-field, and near-field) as recorded with my phone:


Same thing, but the speaker is recorded with a Tascam DR-40X:


It's fun to try!
 
Last edited:

About us

  • What’s Best Forum is THE forum for high end audio, product reviews, advice and sharing experiences on the best of everything else. This is THE place where audiophiles and audio companies discuss vintage, contemporary and new audio products, music servers, music streamers, computer audio, digital-to-analog converters, turntables, phono stages, cartridges, reel-to-reel tape machines, speakers, headphones and tube and solid-state amplification. Founded in 2010 What’s Best Forum invites intelligent and courteous people of all interests and backgrounds to describe and discuss the best of everything. From beginners to life-long hobbyists to industry professionals, we enjoy learning about new things and meeting new people, and participating in spirited debates.

Quick Navigation

User Menu