It actually varies by media.
I often tell a story that I always loved the Mannheim Steamroller Christmas album, but in recent years I found I just didn't really care about it much.
I thought it was just overexposure and/or I had grown tired of the songs.
Then, for the first time in about twenty years, I pulled out the LP rather than the CD to listen to it.
All the joy, the passion I felt for these songs was instantly back.
It made it clear that wasn't that I had grown tired of the songs, I had grown tired of the presentation of the songs from digital.
From the LP all the warmth, the soundstage, the intonation that made me fall in love with the music when I first bought the LP in fall 1984 came flooding back.
I've been a LP person for a long time now, and could give you a laundry list of titles that sound much better on LP than their CD counterparts, but this was the first time I noticed the emotional component of it, and why without that emotional kick, I grew tired of the songs themselves as they just became essentially background noise.