@Stereophonic ...it's not that there is zero merit in some of your points, but you farted in church here, and some members are calling P.U. in the pew. That may not translate.
It probably won't help for you to explain to a group of people from around the globe, who have bought into a platform *and* a process, and who seem to be enamored with what the Extreme is, *and what it can become*...that their thinking is wrong and the baby is ugly.
I think the First Law of Holes applies here: when over your head, stop digging.
I suspect most Extreme owners read Emile's messaging as a celebration, not a fire-alarm.