Yes, the virus is a major problem, and yes there are several arguments about best way to deal with it. I spent a lot of time yesterday listening to John Prine songs, one of the gifted songwriters who had real insight into the human condition. Hearing those songs finally allowed some emotion to break through, and for that I thankful as a lot has been simmering beneath the surface.
Wrt closing the economy, it is easy to argue the benefit if your livelihood is unaffected, as is easy to argue the other side if you or family suffers a death as result of the virus. First half of my life I didn’t have two nickels to rub together, and I’ve known some despair. If you were someone who was out if the workforce a long time and just finally got back to work in the booming economy, maybe you had the first glimmer of hope you’ve had in a very long time. Now the rug gets pulled out from under you and maybe you feel like “shit, not again. Just when things started to be better.”
Not every one in the 17,000,000 newly unemployed will be in this situation, but a hell of a lot of folks who were trying to make it to the end of the month before running out of money don’t know where the $$ is today to feed their kids and make rent.
So to those who adamantly persist in thinking closing the world down is the ONLY solution, I say try wearing the shoes of the newly unemployed facing despair. It is a terrible feeling that often leads to many, many bad choices.
John Prine wrote a song very early in his life about a vet retuning from conflict (Sam Stone) “...there’s a hole in Daddy’s arm where all the money goes...” It breaks my heart to think of those feeling despair in this crisis, some of whom would trade a bout of Wuhan flu to feed their family.