Congrats!
Your post engenders a ton of questions, but I'll only ask a few:
- I really like Jim Smith's book. And he strikes me as a real mensh when I read his posts on the forum. But as he performs the setup, how do you differenciate between your taste and his taste?
- Who designed your room? What kind of treatments are you using?
- CAT Statements come in yet????????????? Will the setup need to be tweaked again?
- And finally, did you ever have that dance party?
I don't think its so much a matter of taste when it comes to working with Jim, but more of maximizing the potential of a system through careful set up. He has developed a certain methodology that is really well outlined in his book, videos, pod casts, and newsletters. A lot of it is trial and error but also he uses an RT Analyzer continuously while playing specific reference tracks on his own Dac/ cables he is very familiar with. Jim actually plugged in his Dac 24 hours before our voicing session, then kept it plugged in his car on the ride over to make sure it was warmed up. When he got to my house, he quickly handed me the Dac with instructions to run it upstairs to my room and plug it in fast to keep it from cooling down.
He had seen my room before and suggested a certain arrangement where the couch was against the long wall and the speakers were out in a more open, spacious area, with the rack on the right side as you face the speakers. But we weren't sure that positioning would yield good sound until the system was playing, and we were prepared to rearrange everything 90 degrees with the couch on the short wall if necessary.
So there was a "conceptual" Plan A and Plan B before he actually arrived for the voicing session. Fortunately Plan A (long wall) sounded great with no odd reflections, so we began to dial in the exact speaker positions with laser measurements, listening, and using the RT Analyzer. The final placement of the speakers, couch, and toe in was symmetric with a margin of error between 1/16th and 1/8th of an inch. Once we found the sweet spot with placement everything just snapped into focus and it was obvious that this was a great sounding lay out.
Its sort of like focusing a camera lens where there is one location where the images are clear and its found by trial and error through turning the dial on the camera. But instead, we were focusing the sound by adjusting the exact footprint of the speakers relative to the seating position. I guess using the camera example, we could say that everybody's eyes are slightly different so the focus point on the camera is not the same for different individuals. Or with ears and music I suppose..... But in the final placement, it was clear to both of us that we had found the sweet spot because everything snapped into focus and imaging, tonality, dynamics, and presence were all fantastic. Could another configuration in the room sound just as good or better? I doubt it, but I wouldn't really know unless I tried. And I'm so happy with the sound and the room lay out that I'm not going to change a thing.
The Statements arrived this week and I set them up yesterday. It took 4 guys to carry 1 amp at a time up the stairs! I'll have more to say about the sound after the system settles in and I can warm up my TT/cartridge and have a nice long listening session. But initial impressions from a brief listen last night was just more, much more, way more, of everything good compared to the JL7's. Just changing amps in the same general location on the floor would't impact or negate any of the hard work we did with speaker placement or room set up.
We'll be having some guests this weekend who want to hear the system, so I do expect a spontaneous dance party to erupt at some point. I'll discuss the room and its design in another thread, but for now its time to start making a play list for the party!