Now, add a pair of Animas for purely classical and jazz listening. I could be open to that...
I'm truly puzzled by all this. I love horns, but mostly for rock, specially the old, quirky kind (prog). Classical and jazz didn't do anything for me on the horns, on the contrary. But rock had a special charm though them.
The big Anima in Munich was great when they cranked some Zeppelin. Not so much when they put the tinkly jazz.
I’m also puzzled... but more just because horns are best (I don’t usually use that word) at jazz and can also clearly be amazing at some smaller scale classical (sonatas and chamber especially) and some of them even nail large scale orchestral.
Though I think for me it’s more about how they connect you with the music rather than a purely sonic assessment. I’m listening to even more classical and jazz than usual since getting the horn n set combo up and running.
Just returned from one of the most enjoyable days listening to another person's system, Animas horns at Mani. The sound was consistently suprising and enjoyable (just my usual caveats on adjusting to non cone bass, and horns torturing the primitive aspects of prog rock mastering, notwithstanding).
In this 100% fun aspect it joins the AG Duos of Blue58 and Apogee Duettas of User211 as slam dunk great transducers (usual considerations on careful setup apply, nothing this good happens by accident).
In the past I've returned to my system after being wowed elsewhere, and been down for a few days, or even longer as I've realised my system would be lacking in many areas.
But in the last couple of years I've returned from Apogees/211s at User211, Pnoes/Mayers at The General, many AG Duos/45s demos at Blue58, recent top Ares Cerat system, all Thrax hybrid system, and now superlative Animas, and gone on to fire up my system.
And realised much as I love what I hear w these horns and ribbons, and how certain aspects properly trump mine, my efforts have really provided massive dividends as I realise I would not swap my sound easily. To feel like I'm not any longer in these guys' slipstreams is an important place for me to have got to, and justifies in my eyes at least the extra mile I've gone to in tweaking out and optimising my sound.
Now, add a pair of Animas for purely classical and jazz listening. I could be open to that...
I'm truly puzzled by all this. I love horns, but mostly for rock, specially the old, quirky kind (prog). Classical and jazz didn't do anything for me on the horns, on the contrary. But rock had a special charm though them.
The big Anima in Munich was great when they cranked some Zeppelin. Not so much when they put the tinkly jazz.
Alex, the issue is not so much that horns don't do prog or fusion, it's just that there is so much disparity btwn tracks, and critically to the stuff that horns lap up ie classical, jazz, vocals.I’m also puzzled... but more just because horns are best (I don’t usually use that word) at jazz and can also clearly be amazing at some smaller scale classical (sonatas and chamber especially) and some of them even nail large scale orchestral.
Though I think for me it’s more about how they connect you with the music rather than a purely sonic assessment. I’m listening to even more classical and jazz than usual since getting the horn n set combo up and running.
Alex, the issue is not so much that horns don't do prog or fusion, it's just that there is so much disparity btwn tracks, and critically to the stuff that horns lap up ie classical, jazz, vocals.
So, on Barry's well sorted Duos, Genesis, Wind And Wuthering: Los Endos sounds compelling. But Trespass: The Knife sounds cut into a zillion pieces.
Rush, Marillion sounds flat and glassy, whether its original or remastered Hemispheres or Clutching At Straws.
These albums sound juicy, textured and dynamic on my lowly tt and Zus.
Just forget about Magma or Voivod on horns, the pulling apart of things is painful.
But put on Snarky Puppy, Nils Frahm, London Grammar or Needlepoint, stuff I'd consider pretty good modern prog related/post prog, and the Duos are commanding and communicative, I'm sure better than my Zus could ever be.
My dilemma on horns in a nutshell.
It really really does.
One analogy is the black coffee without sugar one. This is horns. You can taste every blend directly, some aromatic (classical, jazz, well recorded modern stuff like Nils Frahm), some bitter (prog, fusion, flat multitracked/ProTools eg Queen, Adele).
You become a coffee addict, only happy w the best.
Box spkrs, incl my Zus, more forgiving of poor recordings, could be coffee, white w sugar. More palatable of blend. But disguising or colouring that blend too.
I struggle a little w strong, black unsweeted Expresso double shots, as I do 95% Cacao pure chocolate etc etc.