Correct me pls if I am wrong but since around 30 years all vinyls are made from master studio files , not master tapes.
There is a special technique called Direct Cut developed by Stockfish Recording, but still their vinyls are made from DSD files if I am not mistaken.
How possibly then the vinyl made from digital source may sound better than master studio digital ?
I agree that analog subjectively is often more close to our perception of live music but it has IMO more to do with the way we perceive and process the sound in our brains, not with the format itself.
+2 (its already been plus oned!). But also the actual disk itself in my experience. If someone had told me two years ago that the actual disk itself could be a factor in the quality of CD reproduction (assuming identical data), I would never have believed them. Then I read a Wilma Cozart-Fine interview where she said she received test disks back from several factories for the first batch of the RBCD Mercury reissues and they all sounded different! After experimenting a lot with this myself over the last couple of years, I would venture to suggest the disk itself is possibly even more important than the transport in many cases (within reason of course, no wonderful physical disk will turn my Rega into a dCS).
Agreed, the illusion of reproduced music is a mostly constructed illusion - starting with the particular microphone configuration to be used through to the mastering desk decisions & recording engineering techniques. This is done for all sorts of commercial reasons & to appeal to the target demographic.
But not all recordings are so manipulated - some are more hands off - some, like Greisinger, have done binaural recordings using in ear microphones & playback using in-ear headphones & reported that it was surprisingly realistic.
What I think is ultimately being judged in the playback is the believability of the sound being heard or more accurately a judgement of its adherence to our internal "grammar" of how sound should behave
About Accuphase, Esoteric, Luxman and TEAC?
Sorry you took offense. Thought it was a legitimate question.
Mind my own business? I trust the mods will tell me when I am out of line.![]()
When I have my colonscopy, they give me this stuff you drink which completely cleans your guts. You keep drinking it until what comes out is clear and drinkable itself (not really but play along). Next time I am at my doctor I ask what the liquid is so that you can feed it to your turntable to produce a clean tone. As it is, it ain't drinkable. Not by me anyway....
I don't actually. I hear the distortions in analog and they completely take me out of the experience. Don't need the graphs. I am a victim of my mind always searching for distortions. An occupational hazard of my last corporate job. In the occasions when analog doesn't have these distortions, I enjoy it tremendously as I do with other platforms bringing music that I love to my ear.Amir sees these graphs as proving the superiority of digital.
I don't actually. I hear the distortions in analog and they completely take me out of the experience. Don't need the graphs. I am a victim of my mind always searching for distortions. An occupational hazard of my last corporate job. In the occasions when analog doesn't have these distortions, I enjoy it tremendously as I do with other platforms bringing music that I love to my ear.
I agree. I contacted the the reporter and he said it was a toss up between the above image and this one:From page 1 you could see it was going to be a biased article. Record with scratches all over it - oh please
View attachment 26497
I thought it would be easier to interpret than in the MRI of my brain. Do you hear artifacts in analog John?So why post the graphs then?
I thought it would be easier to interpret than in the MRI of my brain. Do you hear artifacts in analog John?
Do you hear analog distortions John? Because if you do then I don't have to explain it. Do you?If what you wanted to say was that you could hear distortions in analog then maybe a graph with music as the test signal showing those distortions in analog Vs CD may have supported your claim?
I am going to an audiologist soon. When there I am going to ask him for some wax that I can stuff in my ears prior to turning on my turntable from 1980s which I still have (Technics linear tracking). Something tells me I will still hear the distortions but I figured it is worth a try. What brand of wax do you use David and how much do you load up on it in your ears?ThioJoe has a solution for you Amir. If you like your turntable you can keep it, and enjoy it with newer technology without those nasty old records!
david
Do you hear analog distortions John? Because if you do then I don't have to explain it. Do you?
What I listed for Ron are the only ones I can recommend from direct experience Bob. I've only heard the ones you mention casually around, no way to formulate any opinion.
david
![]() | Steve Williams Site Founder | Site Owner | Administrator | ![]() | Ron Resnick Site Owner | Administrator | ![]() | Julian (The Fixer) Website Build | Marketing Managersing |