Zero Distortion: Tango Time

My experience with AtlasSL on SAEC 506 was pretty much similar to Gian's. He has one similar to mine and like it very much on SAEC. Airbearing also has his on the SAEC too if I am not mistaken. But personally I think the AtlasSL sounds at its best on SAT.
 
It sounded not so open not so transparent less dynamic. The tone is too pastel and warm. Not typical of the sound of AtlasSL. I and Pisit, you remember my tone arm guy, tried and retried from start of installing arm and cart four times. I even thought of possible defect of that particular 3012R so I checked by replacing with another different one. But turned out the same sound. Weird. AtlasSL is the only cart went out of its character on 3012R.

Tang

It is strange because it sounded great when I was there.

david
 
  • Like
Reactions: ALF
It sounded not so open not so transparent less dynamic. The tone is too pastel and warm. Not typical of the sound of AtlasSL. I and Pisit, you remember my tone arm guy, tried and retried from start of installing arm and cart four times. I even thought of possible defect of that particular 3012R so I checked by replacing with another different one. But turned out the same sound. Weird. AtlasSL is the only cart went out of its character on 3012R.

Tang

I have heard the Atlas SL on the 3012R in a friend's system. Neutral, open, fast, dynamic.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jeff1225
I have heard the Atlas SL on the 3012R in a friend's system. Neutral, open, fast, dynamic.
Madfloyd right?
That's how the Atlas should sound.
 
It is strange because it sounded great when I was there.

david

Same what tang said plus at the start of this thread Shane too mentioned he did not like the atlas on the 3012r.
 
My cards are four per millimeter or 0.25mm each.
Peter - can you say, as near as you can measure, the length from the 3012R pivot to the stylus?
Tim, this is a better question for David. I’m on vacation at the moment but when I get home, I suppose I could try to measure it. I was quite surprised when I could hear the difference of one card thickness In arm height.
With the 3012-R alignment is done by sliding the base forwards and backwards so pivot to stylus point will change according to cartridge. SME headshell has fixed screw holes. ...
309 mm in my SME3012R/van den Hul BB

I was trying to put card thickness into a perspective I understood.

If we take Francisco's measurement of 309mm for pivot to stylus tip for his vdH Black Bird(?) then, changing the SRA of Francisco's cartridge from, say, 92° to 93° means moving the 3012-R arm roughly 5.4mm or, again roughly, 22 cards in Peter's deck (4 cards = 1mm). If Francisco can hear the difference a single card makes, that means he can hear roughly 45/1000° (0.045° ) of difference in SRA. (If I did the math right ... I"m not a math guy.)

I don't know if there are any tonearms with mechanically adjustable height arm towers that can accurately adjust in 0.25mm increments. The human ear is very sensitive.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ALF and PeterA
Tim, that is what I thought you were trying to figure out. It seems crazy, but one 0.25mm card is audible. Tang hears it too.
Absolutely. David showed me the difference one card makes in startling clarity.
 
Absolutely. David showed me the difference one card makes in startling clarity.
With Master Sig. two cards could mean a worm hole, the tiny cues of movement in sound that unconsciously make your eyes squeezed staring at the front wall with curiosity.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ALF and howiebrou
IMHO David’s biggest gift to WBF is an interface, playing cards, to set VTA...brilliant!

Without repeatable VTA adjustments, who knows what will come out of your speakers.

Cheers!
ALF
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lagonda
IMHO David’s biggest gift to WBF is an interface, playing cards, to set VTA...brilliant!

Without repeatable VTA adjustments, who knows what will come out of your speakers.

Cheers!
ALF
It's not only for repeatability, with the cards you know exactly where you're going and where you've been while figuring out the VTA.

david
 
It's not only for repeatability, with the cards you know exactly where you're going and where you've been while figuring out the VTA.

david

...it is helpful when wandering wistfully in the audio wastelands to have a compass...:)

Cheers!
ALF
 
My casino friend just gave me this special gold plated deck of cards. Adjusting vta correctly is just not enough for the Asians. You have to adjust it with bling. ;)

215E5C9F-3F4C-4040-A7DF-E5393D63D730.jpeg
 
I was trying to put card thickness into a perspective I understood.

If we take Francisco's measurement of 309mm for pivot to stylus tip for his vdH Black Bird(?) then, changing the SRA of Francisco's cartridge from, say, 92° to 93° means moving the 3012-R arm roughly 5.4mm or, again roughly, 22 cards in Peter's deck (4 cards = 1mm). If Francisco can hear the difference a single card makes, that means he can hear roughly 45/1000° (0.045° ) of difference in SRA. (If I did the math right ... I"m not a math guy.)

I don't know if there are any tonearms with mechanically adjustable height arm towers that can accurately adjust in 0.25mm increments. The human ear is very sensitive.

We agree - according to my mental calculus - no calculator available this time! - one card is roughly 0.05 degree. And it is Peter who hears the difference, currently I am focusing in hearing USB cables! However if the system has such sensitivity, Peter had a point when he told us that he had to optimize VTA for each particular LP.

BTW the Graham Phantom III scale has an accuracy of 0.1 mm and includes a level to check horizontality. The Forsell linear tonearm had similar accuracy.
b1.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: tima
We agree - according to my mental calculus - no calculator available this time! - one card is roughly 0.05 degree. And it is Peter who hears the difference, currently I am focusing in hearing USB cables! However if the system has such sensitivity, Peter had a point when he told us that he had to optimize VTA for each particular LP.

BTW the Graham Phantom III scale has an accuracy of 0.1 mm and includes a level to check horizontality. The Forsell linear tonearm had similar accuracy.

This is about the 3012-R Francisco otherwise there are several tonearms that come with screw type VTA adjustment if you like them sonically. The problem with the gauges are that your reading will change depending on your eye level and the scale markings. You also should have heard the differences from a single card adjustment if not then check your system, this isn't voodoo.

david
 
  • Like
Reactions: tima
This is about the 3012-R Francisco otherwise there are several tonearms that come with screw type VTA adjustment if you like them sonically. The problem with the gauges are that your reading will change depending on your eye level and the scale markings. You also should have heard the differences from a single card adjustment if not then check your system, this isn't voodoo.

david

It is why I posted about the Graham - it has a level and an absolute scale, no dependence at all on eye level and operator. Fiddling with a deck of cards is not my cup of tea - sorry! Perhaps some day Tang will post a movie showing him adjusting VTA with his gold cards and I will change my opinion. :)

Surely VTA is not voodoo - vinyl tracking is mainly physics. However we have several classes of users here - those who optimize it for every single LP and take notes on the LP jackets and those who consider that there is a single best setting for all LPs. Or even those who do it with computer instruments and a purpose test LP. A lot to talk about, IMHO.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Gardener
It is much superior to the 3012r on the Lyra atlas. Could be on others I don't know. Mik rates the new SAEC ones quite high

I rate the new Saec 4700 its a fantastic tonearm highly musical great nuance tremendous natural midrange.
 

About us

  • What’s Best Forum is THE forum for high end audio, product reviews, advice and sharing experiences on the best of everything else. This is THE place where audiophiles and audio companies discuss vintage, contemporary and new audio products, music servers, music streamers, computer audio, digital-to-analog converters, turntables, phono stages, cartridges, reel-to-reel tape machines, speakers, headphones and tube and solid-state amplification. Founded in 2010 What’s Best Forum invites intelligent and courteous people of all interests and backgrounds to describe and discuss the best of everything. From beginners to life-long hobbyists to industry professionals, we enjoy learning about new things and meeting new people, and participating in spirited debates.

Quick Navigation

User Menu